Tuesday, May 31, 2005

What Darwin Posited; What Darwinism Has Become

You wrote:

You see what he has cleverly done here? He is equating Darwinism to something that he calls materialist philosophy". I'm not sure that Darwin ever thought that intelligence can only exist unless in evolved from mindless matter. Did he?
Do you see what you have just done? You've assumed that what "Darwinism" is today is necessarily the same as what Darwin intended back in the mid-1800's. I'm not a philosopher, but did not Nietzche latch onto the idea of "survival of the fittest" when he postulated his theory of the "superman?" Was not that then used for such things as eugenics, and Hitler's philosophy of a "master race?"

My point about the small toe, or the appendix, was to illustrate just how distorted Darwin's theory of natural selection has become. People routinely confuse willful adaptation with genetic mutation, and frequently ascribe a "purpose" to "nature's design" in evolution.

* * *
You wrote:

So I would say to the author not to be so anti-ad hominem arguments, as they are exactly what are required to be religious.

Does that necessarily imply that an hominem arguments are the only logical construct to be used when discussing religion?

* * *
You wrote:

At least scientists admit that they don't know it all.

Perhaps that sentence should have read:
At least some scientists admit they they don't know it all.
I don't believe it can be said that all scientists act with equal humility.

Similarly, some people of faith are more than happy to admit they don't know it all. I've read and listened to some of the best theological minds of the 20th and 21st century, and one thing I hear time and again is an admission that at the very center of the Christian faith there exists some profound mysteries.

Yes, there are many people who display a profound sense of arrogance with regard to the things of faith. I've written many times in this space that I have little regard for such people. Aside from doing great damage to the faith, they are displaying a fundamentally flawed response to the central premise of the faith. That's Cornerstone #6, by the way, if I ever get to it. :-)

* * *
As for the use of the term theory ... are you saying that natural selection is a proven fact? Can you cite one instance of proof of a trans-species mutation? Has there ever been an experiment where bacteria in a petri dish have responded to a change in their environment and mutated to a completely different species?

Note: I'll acknowledge that one difficulty here is the definition of the term "species." Some might argue that a bacteria that no longer dies from exposure to some antibiotic is a different species. I'm not so sure that's a proper use of the traditional meaning of the term.

Similarly, are you saying that the "Big Bang" is proven fact? What is scientific "fact?" Can "fact" be established absent a mechanism to provide repeatable and consistent demonstrations of the phenomenon?

* * *
With all due respect, scientists are humans, and humans are subject to many failings, including allowing their personal wishes and desires to enter their studies. This planet is littered with all manner of people who stake a claim for scientific neutrality, but display anything but. Here in the United States, for instance, the Centers for Disease Control published a study that claimed that obesity resulted in over 400,000 deaths per year. It has since been established that the methodology employed in the study is flawed, and that based on the raw numbers the extrapolated value should be closer to 25,000. Yet the CDC has not withdrawn the 400,000 number. Why not? I can only speculate, but here are two reasons: 1) pride, 2) money.

There can be little argument that governmental money chases after things perceived as the most critical to address. Do you think scientists are immune to the lure of grants for their research? Do you think they are immune to the temptation to hedge their findings a bit, perhaps paint a slightly different picture, all to make their particular project more critical than the next fellow's?

Non ad hominem

My you have been prolific on the blog old son!

I don't have the time right now (but will get back to you) to do full justice in responding to all of your points. I did read that article however and the author was poo-poo'ing the use of ad hominem arguments (those arguments that appeal to emotion rather than logic) whilst using them liberally.

I think we have to be careful about such things .. when you say:

"It was then that I sensed that there was another agenda at work -- secular materialism"

Is this sense from your intellect or from your emotional side? (Or were you using The Force again? :-)

Note: We've already concluded that intellect alone will not get one all the way to Jesus Christ. One needs faith, which I would contend is emotionally based (ad hom). So I would say to the author not to be so anti-ad hominem arguments, as they are exactly what are required to be religious.

I did enjoy the article to a degree, but my opinion of the author was dented early on when he wrote:

Darwinism, on the other hand, accepts only the first two causes, because, according to materialist philosophy, intelligence does not exist unless it evolves over time from mindless matter.

You see what he has cleverly done here? He is equating Darwinism to something that he calls "materialist philosophy". I'm not sure that Darwin ever thought that intelligence can only exist unless in evolved from mindless matter. Did he?

Darwin did have a problem, as I believe you and I do, with the Creation account as laid down in Genesis. He goes futher however, in his autobiography Darwin wrote:

"I had gradually come by this time, see that the Old Testament was no more to be trusted than the sacred books of the Hindoos or the beliefs of any barbarian."

I think this offends Christians so they dismiss what is in effect a very successful theory, the theory of natural selection.

I suspect that these days having a small toe or appendix (or not) is neither here or there in the stakes for breeding. As the Human Race moves forward in time I see a homogeneity of variance starting, a settling down, everyone becoming more similar. Necessity is the mother of invention - and necessity for change is reducing as the livestyle of the planet becomes more comfortable.

It's interesting that the author, and about religious folks in general, are always very happy to refer to the Big Bang Theory or the Theory of Evolution, with great joy that these are theories. But if a scientist ever referred to the Theory of An Omnipotent God and Jesus Christ, or Theory of Allah, this would be a great offence. At least scientists admit that they don't know it all.

You wrote:

Why would the state of things prior to the "Big Bang" exist in an apparently steady state and then suddenly change, if not for some outside influence?

Again, this is a dangerous argument for religious people. Discussing the state before the supposed Big Bang. If we do that we should discuss the state before God and what outside influence changed to allow a God. It's like asking "where does the surface of the Earth start?" We may put arbitrary points onto the surface if the Earth (like the poles), but it does not start anywhere.

Likewise God does not start. Likewise the Big Bang did not "start" in the sense that we understand time. Time did not exist before it. If the theory of the Big Bang is correct, and I have seen a whole lot of evidence to support it, then it just was. Talking about temporal events before the start of time is (again) a non-sequitur.

Current song: "Teenage Dirtbag" -- Wheatus

Monday, May 30, 2005

Intelligent Design

I came across this interesting article in defense of "Intelligent Design:"

http://www.techcentralstation.com/052605E.html

What I didn't realize until I got to the bottom of the article is that the author is from Turkey, and is a Muslim (according to the bio at the bottom), though likely a somewhat secular Muslim. But the point is he's not a fundamentalist Christian.

I also found it interesting because it tied in to the posts earlier today.

I do not believe in the purely materialistic view of creation -- never did, even prior to my coming to faith in Christ. I had a vague sense of theism, but nothing concrete. But the idea that everything around us is the result of pure random chance is something that never resonated with me. In college I recall a professor arguing for evolution, and I thought, "No, something is wrong with this argument." He was arguing for the eventual elimination of the appendix or small toe on humans, but such an argument fundamentally refutes the idea of random mutations leading to reproductive advantage. The presence or absence of a small toe on a person does not make them any more or less likely to be reproductively successful, particularly in an age where reproductive choice is not determined solely on survival factors. It was then that I sensed that there was another agenda at work -- secular materialism, but I didn't know it at the time -- and my radar went up, suspicious of what I was hearing.

Note: that's one of my big beefs with materialists -- they impute in evolution a sense of purpose. They'll deny it, but they're language gives them away. They often speak of some change "making sense" ... but of course, "sense" has no place in a world that is a product of pure chance, and has no place particuarly within a mechanism of pure chance.

Another aspect of the secular materialism I could not stomach was the notion that prior to the "Big Bang," all matter in the universe existed in a point of "singularity." That's abstract enough. But to think that such a thing would exist for some period of time and then suddenly -- through some apparent causal effect -- explode in a "Big Bang" without benefit of any outside force ... well, that was too much. Why would the state of things prior to the "Big Bang" exist in an apparently steady state and then suddenly change, if not for some outside influence? But of course, an influence outside the point of "singularity" was not possible; it refutes the idea of singularity.

To add fuel to the fire of those who read my earlier post and view me a heretic, I don't believe in the literal creation of the universe in six solar days. I don't refute the ability of a sovereign and omnipotent God to do that. Rather, I look about this planet and see ample evidence that time has existed for longer than the lineage of humans suggested in the Bible. For instance, the Grand Canyon clearly was not formed by natural erosion in ... what? ... 4,676 years? That means either the earth is older than 4,676 years, or God created the Grand Canyon (and other evidence of long-duration time effects) as they are for some reason unknown to us.

I'm in a philosophical mood ...

I honestly don't see the contradiction here. To assume a creator outside the realm of our natural universe does not, in my mind, refute science. If anything, it elevates my sense of the Holy in God that he could create such an extraordinarily intracate lace of natural laws and physics that would be as we see them today.

Hence my admiration for the article I posted the link to earlier. I see that as a perfectly sensible argument on behalf of "Intelligent Design," though absent any thundering theological condemnation.

Thoughts?

Intelligence and Wisdom

I'm in a bloggin' mood this morning. It's a holiday. I could be doing work-related things. But my brain is just turned off. :-)

Is it possible for a child to be smarter than the parent? I think so ... examples of child prodigies would support that, don't you think? I doubt I was smarter than my parents. They're both pretty smart, but in different ways. From what I understand, my mother tested out with an IQ of something like 160 or so. She had a flair for art, which I think provided her with terrific spatial reasoning capabilities. I have a bit of that ... not much, but a bit.

But that aside, there really is a difference between intelligence and wisdom, isn't there? So while some whiz-kid might know how to calculate 69-factorial in their head, they might be a tad short in the common sense department.

Note: Why 69-factorial? The better calculators of my high-school days allowed scientific notation, but had only two places for the value of the exponent. 69-factorial was the largest number that worked. 70-factorial resulted in an error because the exponent was three digits long. I once set out to hand-calculate 100 factorial to get the exact value. I gave up at about 20.

Note 2: Have you ever heard of the board game called "Diplomacy?" It has no dice, no spinners, no random chance. It consists of a pre-WWI map, tokens that represent armies and navies, and relies entirely on the ability of the players to negotiate alliances and skillfully stab people in the back. There's a whole sub-culture around that game. I used to play that back in high school. I did things like that rather than date girls. I was a pitiful example of a socially awkward geek. I wasn't smart enough to be a "true geek," so I wasn't considered one of the brainiacs. More than anything I was anonymous. I tried to stay that way.

Speaking of Logic ...

I part ways with many of my evangelical brethren on the idea of "proving" the validity of the Christian faith. I hold no such hope of "proving" it. Further, I would argue that the one of the foundational elements of the faith requires that it not be provable. In John 20:24-29, the account is retold of Thomas requiring "proof" of the resurrected Jesus being real. Jesus provides Thomas the opportunity to physically touch his wounds, thus providing proof. Only then does Thomas believe. Jesus then offers a mild rebuke:
Then Jesus told him, "Because you have seen me, you have believed; blessed are those who have not seen and yet have believed." (John 20:29, NIV, emphasis
added)

In other words, the very foundation of the Christian faith is based on the idea that we are to believe what we have not seen for ourselves; believe what we cannot "prove." I may argue for the validity of the supporting evidence, but the ultimate issue -- that Jesus was the Christ -- is a personal decision of faith.

I part ways with some evangelical Christians in my view of the Bible. I do believe that it is inerrant; the inspired and True Word of God. But I can't prove that ... I choose to believe it. What irritated me before I believed -- and still does, for that matter -- is when people try to "prove" the Bible by using verses from the Bible. I'm sure that's a logical fallacy, I'm just not sure the name of the fallacy. A more difficult test is to support the validity of the Bible without relying upon passages within the Bible.

Note: Here there is much scholarly work. I'm not an expert on it, but from what I gather, based on techniques used to validate other antique writings, there is as much reason to believe the authenticity of the written text (not necessarily the message, but the text itself) as there is reason to believe the authenticity of other ancient writings. The book of Luke, for instance, has proven to be an extraordinarily accurate report of events from that time.

I firmly believe that the placing of trust in the Bible as the inspired Word of God is ultimately an act of faith. Logical deduction can be used to take a person a good way in believing that the Bible is a credible ancient text, but that last step -- that the text is God's written word -- necessarily must be an act of faith. I have chosen to believe that the Bible is inherently True; therefore, based on that, I now believe X, Y and Z.

Some might brand me a heretic for writing this, but those who do aren't reading my words very carefully. I'm as strong a believer in the "Inerrancy of Scripture" as any Bible thumper. I'm not a literalist (I don't, for instance, believe Jesus is physically a door, 28" wide and 6'8" high). But I do believe that the Bible as structured represents God's True Word, in ways obvious and in ways obscured.

I just can't "prove" it ... and I don't think it's God's plan for it to be proved.

Belief and Trust ... that's what it's all about. Not proof and acceptance, but belief and trust.

Smart People, Bad Ideas

I enjoyed this line:

People worry about the wrong thing at the wrong time and apply their intelligence in ways that doesn’t serve the greater good of whatever they’re trying to achieve.

I've seen this a million times, especially in meetings of people. It's almost inevitable that in any group discussion the main point will be obscured by a flurry of side topics which, if pursued, end up taking the whole discussion down some side street. I want to scream, "No! The main point is back here!" But I'm rarely listened to. :-)

* * *
I'm not so sure C. S. Lewis made the argument that Christianity must be right because nobody has proven it wrong. I recall him very forcibly arguing that atheism is logically unsupportable. He used that as a springboard to argue for the existence of God. Of course, the existence or non-existence of God is something that will never be "proven."

But I would advise some caution in negating the argument, "Since it's not been disproven, then there's a chance it's correct" line of reasoning. That is what's used all the time in the scientific community. The "Big Bang" will never be "proven" ... the best it'll ever achieve is a growing weight of supporting evidence. But it will always remain a theory. And therefore, just because nobody has disproven it, it doesn't make it so.

Note: And please don't tell me that scientists keep "theory" and "fact" neatly separated in their minds -- they don't. Scientists are no different from other people in that they have various agendas (agendi?) they're chasing, and the line often blurs. The theory of evolution is a good example of this -- supporting that theory as fact very nicely serves the agenda of refuting religion and building a sort of secular faith.

That said, Scott Berkun's blog was very well done. Years ago, in college, I took a course in logical argumentation. Not debate, but the various logical constructs and fallacies that one can employ. It was rather eye-opening. Once I was learned about the various fallacies, I was able to see them employed in things like newspaper articles. I don't remember all the different fallacies now, but one I recall is the "false strawman" fallacy. In that fallacy a false hypothesis is posited and then vigorously refuted. Then, upon the negation of that false hypothesis, a second hypothesis is then introduced and assumed true, simply because the other one has been proven false.

  • Consider "A"
  • I argue that "A" is incorrect.
  • Therefore, "B"
Of course, the negation of "A" does not necessarily allow the conclusion of "B." That's the fallacy.

It is tempting to think that someone like C. S. Lewis was employing this "false strawman" argument: "Consider atheism ... I argue atheism is unsupportable ... therefore Christianity." But I'd argue that he did not do that. I'd argue that his logic was more:
  • Consider "A"
  • I argue that "A" is incorrect.
  • Now consider "B"
  • Here are my arguments for "B"
  • Therefore, "B" is correct
Of course, you may not agree with my assessment. But I know I'm right. I'm always right! :-)

Note: don't go dissin' my boy C. S. ... you know that gets me steamed. :-)

* * *
So the French have voted "non" to the E.U. Constitution. I understand that Holland has its vote this Wednesday. Speculation in the conservative press here is that the advocates of the E.U. will simply keep bringing the issue to a vote until they receive the "oui" vote they desire. Then it will never be subject to a vote again. How's the British press playing the referendum of Sunday?

"Well, at least I was right"

A highly enjoyable (for me) read at:

http://www.scottberkun.com/essays/essay40.htm

1. It has a connection to the current Star Wars theme of the Dark Side being the quick and easy way when the writer says:

"I chose speed and power over control, and I usually lost. So like pool, when it comes to defusing smart people who are defending bad ideas, you have to find ways to slow things down."

2. He refers indirectly to C.S. Lewis when saying:

"“My plan A is the best because no one has explained how it will fail” know that there is a logical gap in this argument. Simply because no one has described how it will fail, doesn’t necessarily make it the best plan. It’s possible than plans B, C, D and E all have the same quality ..."

3. He believes in "lead, follow, or get out of the way" (essay 42)

4. He left Microsoft after 10 years (essay 41) -- so cannot be all bad? :-)

So, I of course, selected to like his articles, and would be interested in your opinion. Props to Scott Berkun, keep going.

I wonder if, when we were kids, you and I were smarter than our parents? And so (by Scott's argument) turned out in such a fashion as to support "bad" ideas? Would this be consistent with God saying "do not eat from the tree of knowledge of good and evil", thus bringing upon ourselves tsunamis and the like?

Genesis 2 (KJV)

17 "But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it: for in the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die."

It's a holiday today!

Current song: "Everybody's Talking At Me" -- Harry Nilsson

PS. Looking forward to "Cinderella Man" - thanks for the tip.

Sunday, May 29, 2005

"For Yoda So Love the World..." -- Jedi 3:16

No, it doesn't suprise me at all that there'd be 390,000 people who'd respond with "Jedi" as their religion. I'll bet there'd be similar numbers (perhaps greater numbers) here in the United States. What would be interesting is to ask them what that religion entails ... what exactly they believe in subscribing to "Jedi" as their religion. I doubt it would there's be much agreement from one follower of Jedi to the next. "The Force" might be a common theme, but then ask them what "The Force" is.

* * *
Allow me to rephrase my earlier statement -- either Jesus is God incarnate; crucified, dead, and now alive again; given full dominion and authority over all ... or he's a dead Jewish carpenter.

* * *
The movie buzz I'm hearing is that "Cinderella Man," a story of a depression-era yoeman boxer named Jim Braddock who defeated heavyweight champion Max Baer in 1935, is a terrific movie. It opens in a week, I think, but the pre-release buzz is strong. It's directed by Ron Howard (of "A Beautiful Mind" and "Apollo 13" fame) and stars Russell Crowe and Renee Zellweger. I like Russell Crowe's acting. For the longest time I thought Renee Zellweger was a lightweight, but she's impressed me of late. That's one I'll probably go see. I won't be seeing the Star Wars movie ... just have no interest at all.

In thinking about the time setting of "Cinderella Man," my mind went back to the original Star Trek series and the "City on the Edge of Forever" episode. That's the one when the Enterprise comes upon a sort of time portal (which ran WebSphere), through which went a drug-deranged Dr. McCoy. It's set in the depression era and starred Joan Collins as Edith Keeler. A quiet memorable episode.

"Assassins!" -- Dr. McCoy

"He knows, doctor. He knows." -- Mr. Spock.

The Force is strong with you

You ask:

Do you think there is an existence, a reality, that is beyond what can be explained by physical science?

Yes. I would call it an "existence" yes, but it might not be "a reality". The reality of something should be in this Universe. Anything outside of our Universe could be defined to be "unreal" could it not? After all, it cannot be measured. "Unreal" but not "imaginary" perhaps? I'm not sure where the boundary lies between those two words.

You wrote:

Either Jesus is "the way and the truth and the light" or he isn't.

Maybe. But one needs first to define "the way" and "the truth". If those terms are relative themselves then where does that lead us? With our limited brains your statement might be how it seems. But our limited brains believe lots of things.

At the end of the day, for me, as my life is all too finite I may as well believe in something and I choose to believe in Jesus. Had I an infinite amount of time I might look into the matter far more closely. Perhaps when individual humans live for millions of years they will choose to do so?

on:

Many fall victim to the loose, easy "spirituality" that is eschewed by the likes of Oprah Winfrey.

Lucas warns us about this in Star Wars 5: The Empire Strikes Back

LUKE "Is the dark side stronger?
YODA "No, no. Easier, quicker, more seductive."

You may laugh, but 390,000 people, when asked during the last UK (2001) census, put "Jedi" in the religion box. It's "true" see http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/2757067.stm

Current song: "Somebody" -- Depeche Mode

Friday, May 27, 2005

Reality Beyond Reality?

Your post brings up a fundamental question -- is there a reality beyond the physical reality of our universe? I'm not talking about parallel universes or anything of the sort ... I'm referring to the super-natural. Do you think there is an existence, a reality, that is beyond what can be explained by physical science?
  • If the answer is "Yes," then perhaps we can muse on whether our soul exists in this different realm.
  • If the answer is "No," then there's a fundamental problem we must face squarely. If we deny the supernatural, we deny God. By definition God is not of the natural, for he created the natural. If God were comprised of the natural, he could not have existed prior to himself in order to create himself.

For what it's worth, I believe our being (our "soul") is beyond the natural. It does not consist of photons, or energy waves, or quarks or dark matter, or whatever. It is something other than that; something God created, but something not accessbile to our measurement or understanding.

* * *

As for "spirituality," the danger lurks for people who are truly seeking God, but fall prey to the seduction of these other forms of "spirituality." I am intentionally setting aside the question of predestination of "the elect" and assuming for the moment that someone who has a stirring in their heart to seek that "something" beyond themselves is being called by God. Those who are so moved face a virtual cafeteria of options. Many fall victim to the loose, easy "spirituality" that is eschewed by the likes of Oprah Winfrey.

Again, I fall back to what I see is this inescapable logic -- if Christianity is true, then all other religions and ideas of spirituality are false; if any other religion is true, then Christianity is false. They are mutually exclusive. Either Jesus is "the way and the truth and the light" or he isn't.

On spirituality, the soul and self

I guess for non-believers in the Christian faith to be "spiritual" is not a bad thing. If they haven't been elected to follow Jesus at least they are recognizing that the human is more than just a physical body. I hope !

It's weird really, Christians and Spiritualists alike believe that we have a quality (let's call it "the soul"), and that this soul is somehow separate from our physical being. But this "soul" does not register on any scientific apparatus known to mankind. So what is it? It's not an electromagnetic phenemenon. Did we invent the soul for survival purposes?

We have not found the soul with instruments, but to me, as a scientist, the soul could only exist (in this Universe) in the small spaces that are excluded from our intruments. These are very small distances, but add up to the entire Universe. All these tiny bits of space that we cannot look inside of (uncertainty principle) add up to a Universe. So if we cannot see what the Universe is really made of, then could the soul perhaps live in those spaces?

Hypothetical question: if I could copy your physical body and the electronic state of your brain exactly (like resuming a PC from hibernate), would that copy be "BAGWELL"? Who is "BAGWELL"? Is "BAGWELL" defined by his soul? And can the soul be copied?

I've been musing on this problem lately and have been kind of losing "myself". It appears to me that the "self" doesn't really exist. If you think about it long enough you get lost (or at least I do) in the feeling that the whole Universe is one connected thing, and that none of us are "real".

But while thinking about it, and getting lost, ones attention wanders and you might get eaten by a lion. So natural selection has ensured that we don't think about such things. :-) (Or better, we don't think about such things because those of us that did died out and those of us that survived are a different breed).

Current song: "Groove is in the heart" -- Deee Lite

Thursday, May 26, 2005

"Spirituality"

I was reading a piece by Mark Steyn, columnist found in many different newspapers. This paragraph caught my eye:
Motoring through Gloucestershire a couple of Sunday nights back, I caught a Radio Four programme called Something Understood, with Mark Tully, one of those kinda-sorta-religious shows which seem to be as far as the BBC’s so-called Religious Affairs Unit is prepared to go these days. Its theme that week was the great revival of religion and ‘spirituality’, terms which were used by Mr Tully pretty interchangeably. It’s true that at the moment the shine seems to be off atheism, and many folks find secular society vaguely insufficient. But religion — i.e., Islam, Judaism, Christianity, etc. — isn’t quite the same as ‘spirituality’, a mostly bogus category created for people who want to feel good about themselves without having to get up early on Sunday or give up activities to which they’re partial but most Churches aren’t. ‘Spirituality’ is pretty thin gruel next to your average ‘organised religion’, and my bet is the organised guys will win in the end. But in the meantime we have to put up with a lot of narcissist cults designed to make unsatisfied secular Westerners feel good about themselves.

I don't know much about Radio Four's "Something Understood," nor much about the BBC in general. But I like Steyn's characterization of the use of the phrase "spirituality." I've always been suspicious of it because I've heard it used in so many ways, relating to so many thing -- from traditional Christianity all the way to crystals, aromatheraphy and yoga "spirituality." I don't like the word.

In fact, I don't much care for the term "religion" when speaking of Christinity either. The term "faith" is better, but not perfect. I'm struggling to come up with a word that best means "belief in an immutable Truth." But even that might not do it, because there's an element of trust in addition to belief, and the simple word trust doesn't convey the proper depth of commitment. Perhaps I'm just overthinking things. :-)

I'm in Phoenix right now, going home to Tucson later tonight.

Hope all is well with you!

Wednesday, May 25, 2005

I've Been There!

That aerial photo you referenced is a military aircraft outdoor storage facility. The air in Tucson is so dry that there's virtually no ability for things to rust. I took a tour of that facility once -- it was fascinating riding in the bus between row afer row of moth-balled aircraft. There's a similar facility for commercial aircraft -- row after row of variously logo'd commercial aircraft.

Tucson is a place where people from around the world come to train to fly various aircraft. Given the vast expanse of desert, there's little problem with risking civilian populations if a plane were to crash. Also, there are sufficient mountains so various wind and air conditions can be experienced.

There ... there's your Tucson Chamber of Commerce message for the day!

Team America: World Police

You live near Tucson right? Check this out !!

http://maps.google.com/maps?q=Tucson,+AZ&ll=32.155223,-110.828598&spn=0.009506,0.014098&t=k&hl=en

No song: In the office

Tuesday, May 24, 2005

Pre-Existence Existence

I saw the movie "Team America," and I laughed probably as much as you did. The movie skewered pretty much everybody -- on the left and the right. In that sense it's a lot like the cartoon called "South Park," which is in the United States but I don't know if it's seen anywhere else. They have no sacred cows. It's hilarious.

* * *
Interesting question ... since I did not ask to be created, does that mean I should not be held responsible for my actions after having been created? Extend the logic -- if the argument is one should not be held accountable in the afterlife for not believing in Jesus Christ, why then should one be held accountable in this life for committing a series of horrible murders? Honestly, what's the difference?

That's not a foolish question ... it gets back to the basic issue of morality: if God exists, and he is the omnipotent creator we believe him to be, then of course he has the right to establish what is right and wrong. If belief in Christ is his dictate, who are we to say it's unfair to hold us accountable just because we were created?

Note: actually, the issue is considerably more complex if one subscribes to the doctrine of the elect. If the decision as to who will believe and who will not is made prior to creation, and I was created as one of the non-elect, then why should I be punished for eternity for not believing in something I was not pre-determined to believe. See that dilemma? I don't have a clue how to answer that.

If, on the other hand there is no original creator, no surpreme being, no moral authority ... then how exactly are we to determine right from wrong? Logically there is absolutely no way one can say there is a notion of right or wrong if there isn't a level at which the issue is definitively resolved. I know most reject that logic, but it truly is inescapable.

* * *
I'm watching a show on TV about Alaskan King Crab fishing in the Barring Sea. Supposedly it's the most dangerous profession on earth. Pitching seas, frozen decks, frigid waters, and 500 pound crab cages slamming to and fro on the deck. The crew fishes frantically for 72 straight hours, and one false step could mean being pitched into the icy waters to almost certain death. All for crab. It's good, I'll admit. But I'd just as soon have a chip-butty. Hmmmmm ... good!

Young Americans

You wrote:

What's more terrifying: nothing at all, or a Holy God who will judge one's every act and every thought?

The latter is far far more terrifying. I believe that I know what it is like to not exist, I think that I did that for approximately 5,113,500,000,000 days during the existence of this universe - and it holds no terror for me.

You can see the problem with this:

“I didn’t ask to be born God, surely you should put me back into the state that I was in before you incarnated me? If I had asked to have been born then I guess it’s fair enough for you to judge me. But as I believe that I didn’t ask to be born, why send me to an eternity of pain, just because I did not believe in Jesus Christ?”

On:

What's the value of "American Values" if they're not God's values?

Huh? I'm sure that God believes that we all have the right to drink Pepsi.

But seriously, first of all, what are “American Values”? Is there such a generalized set of values? Does anybody know? If there are, are they the same as those espoused in the puppet-movie “Team America” (a film which I could not help laugh at)? In this movie American soldiers are defeating terrorists, they always get their man. At one point they destroy the majority of Paris, but it’s ok as they get their bearded terrorist. This is quite a satirical insight into how the rest of the world (outside of the coalition) sees American foreign policy.

But you’re absolutely right, the question is a non-sequitur, it is the wrong way around, it should be “Do American Values undermine those of God”?

Current song: “I'm afraid of Americans" - David Bowie

++++

I saw the Netscape 8 announce (thank you slashdot!) I even went to download it and the first thing I saw was a security alert on the new rendering engine so I think I will wait a while.

Monday, May 23, 2005

Fearing Loss?

Welcome back from vacation, good sir. I hope you enjoyed yourself and came back relaxed and refreshed.

I've not yet seen the Star Wars movie, and probably will not. I'm not much of a fan of that franchise, and generally not much of a fan of science fiction. As to what Yoda was supposed to mean when he said, "Attachment leads to jealousy. The shadow of greed, that is. Train yourself to let go of everything you fear to lose" ... I can't begin to guess. But it got me thinking ... is it fear of losing, or fear of realizing something that terrifies people?

I've always wondered about this question: if we could know -- with absolute certainty -- that upon death there truly is nothing at all, would people be more or less frightened of death? Put another way, are we afraid of death because of it's the end, or because it's a beginning? What's more terrifying: nothing at all, or a Holy God who will judge one's every act and every thought?

I've come to fear the latter more than the former, which leads me to appreciate gift of Grace through Christ. I'm no better at the "spiritual disciplines" as I was before (that is to say, awfully negligent), but there's something really pounding in my heart and head -- it's all about Christ. What I do with that realization I do not yet know.

* * *
I saw a blog today that posed this question: "Is Christianity undermining American values?" I thought about that a bit, then I thought -- that question completely misses the point, doesn't it? What's the value of "American Values" if they're not God's values? And if one makes the assumption that "American Values" are a subset of "God's Values" (which is not necessarily a given, obviously), then Christianity by definition can't undermine those value. Unless, of course, the term "Christianity" means something different; or the values being considered aren't God's values. If "American Values" are opposed to God's values, then the true Christian must strive to undermine those values. The tough question is this -- what means may a Christian employ to resist those things opposed to the Lord?

* * *
Netscape 8.0 is out ... it has a dual rendering engine -- Firefox and IE. Cool.

Sunday, May 22, 2005

Sympathy for the devil?

Apologies for the delay my brother, I have been en vacance à Paris for the last few days. Paris is a beautiful city and I can recommend the open bus tour.

I append this from a window manager called "icewm" running on a Linux distribution named "Gentoo", and it is singularly the fastest desktop that I have ever used. I can boot and do work within 45 seconds compared to the 400+ seconds on my WinXP rig on the same hardware. But, I can do less work in the long run (no iTunes or some other key apps), and how often do I boot up these days anyway? Still, Linux improves.

I checked out the site, I will be very interested indeed in what you discover about Mr. Sprouls interpretation of the Christian Doctrine. It's a tricky one this "everything is going according to God's plan" vs. "humans do not act according to God's will". Logically one should suppose that our human will is not aligned with God's perfect plan, and that that is allowed, even with a perfect plan. Had the Sproul works at that site been free of charge I would have downloaded them myself. I am sure that he is being exploited by middle men :-)

Having seen Star Wars 3 today, George Lucas (in the guise of a small green Master Jedi called Yoda) said:

"Attachment leads to jealousy. The shadow of greed, that is. Train yourself to let go of everything you fear to lose."

This I found quite interesting. I guess Lucas was talking about the fear of loss of the things we enjoy in life? But in our lives, what do we really fear to lose? Perhaps we fear to lose our very "existence" and have a very hard time in letting go? Therefore we invent for ourselves an afterlife?

If the Bible is not "true" is that why the Bible is the way it is and so popular ?

The film was kind of tragic the way the story portrayed the decline into evil of Anakin Skywalker/Darth Vader as a result of his desire to hang onto those he loved dear. Good and Evil, are they absolute or relative terms?

I don't know, but I for one actively want an afterlife.

And now that you're living in such a hot place you're attracted to cold web sites I see!

Current song: "Bo Weevil Song" - Eddie Cochran

Wednesday, May 18, 2005

Cool Blog ...

Completely unrelated to this blog's topic thread, but the pictures on this site are about as cool -- pardon the pun -- as I've seen:

http://simonc.f2o.org/south/

A fellow Brit, down at some South Pole scientific station.

Tuesday, May 17, 2005

Further Study

I am of late enamored by the MP3 series of R.C. Sproul. After your latest set of questions -- and my inability to answer them -- I searched around on the site and found a series titled, "The Providence of God." The description reads:
In this series, R.C. brilliantly shows the wisdom and power of God's rule, clarifying how God can guide all events without initiating human wickedness or destroying human freedom. Six 30 Minute Episodes.
The direct link to the series is:
https://ecom.ligonier.org/ecom/products.asp
?idDept=M&idCategory=&idFamily=PRO01
&title=The%20Providence%20of%20God
I found the headings for each MP3 quite interesting:
  • What is Providence?
  • God Makes it Happen.
  • God or Chance?
  • Is God Responsible for Human Wickedness?
  • What About Human Freedom?
  • If God Knows Our Needs, Why Pray?
I purchased the series and am listening to the first. I'll let you know what I learn from this.
Quote: "The study of providence is one of the most fascinating, important and difficult areas of theology."
I'd agree with that! :-) He cited as an introduction the very things you and I were batting back and forth.

P.S. -- I think you'd like R.C. Sproul ... very logical, very smart.