Monday, April 11, 2005
Sequoia
This is a pretty well served location, it has clearly been designed for use by those at the top of the slippery pole, ie. executive types. One spends all ones life trying to earn a living and then one dies, one may as well enjoy it on the way?
Yes, we get around.
Your cornerstone #5 sir?
Current Song: "I Get Around" -- The Beach Boys
Sunday, April 10, 2005
Airport Blogging
The "movements" I was referring to was the "charismatic" movement within the Christian faith. I'm not sure I have a good definition of it, but it's a movement that believes that the manifestation of the Spirit through outward gifts such as "speaking in tongues" is their preferred method of worship. The Pentecostal Church falls into this camp. There may be others. As I mentioned, this is clearly not me.
I have no proof that Ms. Jolie is truly under the influence of the devil ... my comment really stems from two things: some very weird behavior on her part when she was married to Billy Bob Thornton (exchanging viles of each others' blood, for instance) and this almost hypnotic charm she seems to have over men who fall prey to her wiles. It may just be a stronger sense of sexual confidence ... who knows?
Do genetics play a role in success? Your example of the 100 meter hurdles points to an obvious example ... I will never, never, ever run a 4-minute mile. It doesn't matter how much I train. I will never, never, ever be able to dunk a basketball on a 10-foot rim. (I used to be able to touch the rim, but not even that any more!) But it's not limited to physical activities -- not everyone can be a mathematical genius; not everyone can counter deep.thought's frickin' pawn gambit thing he does! :-)
What about business? There's a bit more gray there, don't you think? For instance, I think Bill Gates was as much "in the right place at the right time" as he was business savvy. If one could wipe from everyone's memory Bill Gates' success at Microsoft, could he repeat it today, not relying on his current name and reputation? Maybe. Maybe not.
London Heathrow
"When I'm presenting I am "on stage," giving a portrayal that is not really me"
That's interesting, I think that is probably true for most folks, but perhaps it's more highly developed in your good self? If a Hollywood actress such as Ms. Jolie never learned to act then she wouldn't be in Hollywood I guess. There are some physical activities, like the 100 metres sprint that not everyone can be a world record holder in, due to the way that they are put together (their genes). It would seem that there can only be a handful of Bill Gates types too, monstrously successful businessmen, so I assume that their success is also due to their genetics, the way their brains are constructed? Or is Satan powering their success?
Current Song: Muzak from the TGIF's next to me
Saturday, April 09, 2005
Charismatic People and Movements
Note: One example that comes to mind is Madonna. I don't much care for her music or her viewpoint on things, but it would be hard for me to argue that she's a strong-willed, confident and at least from a public relations perspective, persuasive and energentic personality.
Another woman that comes to mind -- very much in the news of late -- is Angelina Jolie. She is, I think, "charismatic," but in a way that is uniquely feminine: she exudes a certain confident sexuality that in and of itself is strong, confident and persuasive. I'm not much taken by her charms simply because I think she's operating under the influence of some dark forces, but there's no denying lots of men in Hollywood seem unable to resist her allure. Brad Pitt, if the stories in the tabloids are true, is the latest.
Do I think Jesus had charisma? Yes, but not in a "snake-oil salesman" sort of way. If the Bible is true and we are to understand that Jesus was singularly without sin -- either of commission or omission; either of deeds or thoughts -- then it must have been a striking thing to witness him. Every act, every word, every thought, every deed -- all perfectly obedient to the will of the perfect Creator. I can imagine there must have been a confidence there that was without pride or boastfulness; humility without weakness; strength without malice. He was, I suspect, quite an arresting person when he was in human form on this earth.
There's little question that in today's world that people possessing charisma often achieve what they set out to achieve. The best salesmen are charismatic. Many of the larger churches in America are led by very charismatic pastors, sometimes ones who eventually stumble and fall due to the intoxication of their success -- Jim Bakker of the 1980's; Jimmy Swaggart, etc.
Of the two approaches you wrote of -- Jung's charismatic influence vs. Freud's methodical process -- I think I would trust Freud's more. I am suspicious of charismatic influence, though I am not immune to it. It's just that for the person who possesses it in large measure, it can be quite a narcotic. It takes a person with deep roots to use such natural charisma for good.
Interesting comment you made about my supposed charisma. Odd since I don't sense any such thing, but then again I witness myself from the inside, and I see a different picture. When I'm presenting I am "on stage," giving a portrayal that is not really me, but rather a projection I muster. That is why, I think, I am so exhausted after such times -- I spend considerable energy being someone I suspect I am not. The same holds for social gatherings -- I "put on a mask" and exhaust myself in the process.
I was thinking about this the other day when I was talking to a co-worker of mine about the Christian faith. He is not a believer, yet he is clearly seeking. He expressed some discomfort with the notion of being really demonstrative with one's faith -- holding up a Bible, closing one's eyes and waving one's hands in the air. I had to agree with him. Such is simply not something I will ever do. Which brings up this question: is that necessarily bad? Call it wishful thinking, but I would like believe that there is a place for quiet, introspective belief. If not, then I'm in for a difficult journey.
About Charisma
Taking that particular scene from Pulp Fiction a little further didn’t Jules then tell Vincent that a dog wasn’t a filthy animal, because a dog had personality, and personality goes a long way ..?
You mentioned Carl Gustav Jung, I don’t know a lot about him but have been reading some references to him on the web this past week. Did you know that when he first met Sigmund Freud they apparently had a non-stop 13 hour long conversation? Freud’s son is on record as saying that during dinner Jung spoke directly and exclusively to Freud, ignoring the very existence of the rest of Freud’s family!
Jung did subscribe to dualism as you mention, the idea of good and evil, the yin and yang, the two sided nature of everything. He (apparently) managed to reconcile dualism with monism in this work Mysterium Coniunctionis. I find no evidence for his belief if any in a triune nature from what I have read so far. There are some things that sparked in my mind as I was investigating Jung:
He was into the Philosopher’s Stone and Alchemy. We talked about this stone in previous appends, so I found this connection statistically uncalled for. Jung time and again pointed out the affinity and contrast between alchemical figures and those of Christianity, demonstrating a sort of mirror-like analogy not only between the stone of the philosophers and the image of Christ, but between alchemy and Christianity themselves. Alchemy, said Jung, stands in a compensatory relationship to mainstream Christianity, rather like a dream does to the conscious attitudes of the dreamer. The Stone of alchemy is in many respects the stone rejected by the builders of Christian culture, demanding recognition and reincorporation into the building itself. Maybe this has something to do with my Christian friends not letting their children watch Harry Potter?
Jung also believed in the charismatic healer. I’m talking psychoanalysis here. Freud believed in a “method” for treating “mentally ill” patients. These “poor unfortunates” could be helped through the application of psychoanalytical method, the treatment often involving hypnotherapy, where the “answer” would usually have something to do with the patient realising that his problems were of a sexual nature (and the repression thereof). Freud felt that healing could be garnered through fastidious attention to a detailed method whereas Jung on the other hand believed that the patient could only really be healed through the charismatic personality of the doctor administering the method. I found this interesting coupled with that scene from Pulp Fiction that you started off!
So then I started to think about charismatic people. While I do believe that there have been many charismatic women throughout history, the term is usually applied to men. As an insult you might hear the phrase “he has had a charisma bypass” but you rarely hear the insult “she has had a charisma bypass”. Either all women have natural charisma, or it is not expected of them? Furthermore, our very our Prince Charles is getting married today and I cannot think of a better example of an individual totally lacking in any sort of charisma whatsoever, if indeed there are different sorts.
Incidentally, UK parliament has now dissolved in advance of the general election which takes place on May 5th. The leader of the Conservative Party, the opposition to Tony Blair’s government (Michael Howard), has himself been described as someone who has had a “charisma bypass”!
Then there is you oh bagwell, singularly you have scored the highest feedback marks from the recipients of your presentations, and I believe that partly you do so through your charismatic delivery. Reading your posts to this blog one cannot fail to get a sense of your charismatic personality and good charm.
Do you believe that Jesus was a charismatic teacher and leader? I feel that he may well have been. Was it these personal characteristics that helped people to follow him, or was it predominantly the miracles?
I am going to the Palisades tomorrow and need to return to the UK on Thursday so I unfortunately will not see you on this trip my brother.
Current music: The Godfather Soundtrack (aka Italian dinner music)
PS. We have had our first comment from Elaine to my “Power of three” append! Thank you Elaine, I’m still going with Jesus as the ID because he had personality.
Sunday, April 03, 2005
"Are You Jewish?"
Vincent: "Want some bacon?"What does that have to do with Sigmund Freud and you question? Probably not a lot, except that Sigmund Freud was a non-practicing, almost atheist Jew. So I'm wondering how much of the doctrine of the Trinity he would have known about. The idea of God as "Three in One" as we have it is very foreign, and almost blasphemous to the Jewish mind.
Jules: "No, man. I don't eat bacon."
Vincent: "Are you Jewish?"
Jules: "No, I ain't Jewish ... I just don't dig on swine, that's all."
Bottom line: "I dunno."
As to your question whether God created man, or the other way around ... I would guess that Freud -- in his later years in particular -- would have thought that God was simply a fabrication of our minds. That notion has been used to unfortunate effect by many since Freud's time to undermine the Kingdom of God. I'm not a fan of Freudian psychology, or any psychology for that matter, because I have little sense of its efficacy. But I could be shading reality with my own personal experiences there.
Wasn't it Jung that felt that man had a duality, not a triune nature?
I can't handle too much of that philosophical or psychological stuff ... too abstract. It's kinda like a Java Bean ... :-)
The power of three
I was walking through Itchen Valley Country Park on Friday musing on the triune nature of man and God (among other things). I wondered if Freud was borrowing from the triune nature of God when he came up with the following for the structure of the human mind:
THE ID: (“It”): functions in the irrational and emotional part of the mind. At birth a baby’s mind is all Id - want want want. The Id is the primitive mind. It contains all the basic needs and feelings. It is the source for libido (psychic energy). And it has only one rule --> the “pleasure principle”: “I want it and I want it all now”. In transactional analysis, Id equates to "Child".
Id too strong = bound up in self-gratification and uncaring to others
THE EGO: (“I”): functions with the rational part of the mind. The Ego develops out of growing awareness that you can’t always get what you want. The Ego relates to the real world and operates via the “reality principle”. The Ego realises the need for compromise and negotiates between the Id and the Superego. The Ego's job is to get the Id's pleasures but to be reasonable and bear the long-term consequences in mind. The Ego denies both instant gratification and pious delaying of gratification. The term ego-strength is the term used to refer to how well the ego copes with these conflicting forces. To undertake its work of planning, thinking and controlling the Id, the Ego uses some of the Id's libidinal energy. In transactional analysis, Ego equates to "Adult".
Ego too strong = extremely rational and efficient, but cold, boring and distant
THE SUPEREGO: (“Over-I”): The Superego is the last part of the mind to develop. It might be called the moral part of the mind. The Superego becomes an embodiment of parental and societal values. It stores and enforces rules. It constantly strives for perfection, even though this perfection ideal may be quite far from reality or possibility. Its power to enforce rules comes from its ability to create anxiety.
The Superego has two subsystems: "Ego Ideal" and "Conscience". The Ego Ideal provides rules for good behaviour, and standards of excellence towards which the Ego must strive. The Ego ideal is basically what the child’s parents approve of or value. The Conscience is the rules about what constitutes bad behaviour. The Conscience is basically all those things that the child feels mum or dad will disapprove of or punish.
Superego too strong = feels guilty all the time, may even have an insufferably saintly personality
Couple this with:
Then God said, "Let us make man in our image, in our
likeness…”
Genesis 1:26 (NIV)
is there an obvious association between the triune nature of God and man? Do they map in this fashion?
The Father – The Superego
The Son – The Id
The Holy Spirit (Ghost) – The Ego
I've never seen this connection made, would the id and ego be reversed? What do you think?
This of course begs the question, "did God create man or did Man create god?" Or was Freud just having a laugh?
Current song: “The Magic Number” – De La Soul
Saturday, April 02, 2005
Pope John Paul II
John Paul II now stands before the full Glory of Christ.
“His master replied, ‘Well done, good and faithful servant! You have been faithful with a few things; I will put you in charge of many things. Come and share your master's happiness!’ (Matthew 25:21, NIV)
The Nature of Blogger
Nature of Sin
"Nobody is perfect!" Is the common refrain. That would be correct -- mankind is inherently sinful, or inherently imperfect. But the underlying thinking (or wishful thinking) by most people when they say, "Nobody is perfect" is really: "God knows we're not perfect ... he takes that into account and overlooks our minor imperfections if we just work hard at avoiding the big ones."
That's a very common way of thinking. Major faith traditions -- Judiasm, Islam, Budhism, Hinduism -- are all based on the notion that our efforts in this world to minimize the degree of imperfection is what matters. There's where the radical departure with Christianity exists: the Christian faith is built upon the idea that no matter how hard we try, no matter how good we think we're being, we're still far, far short of the perfect standard demanded by a Holy God.
From a purely logical point of view, if the "One True God" exists and what I've suggested about his Holy nature is correct, then sin has nothing to do with behavior relative to what the person believes. It has everything to do with what God expects. An atheist who doesn't believe in God doesn't change the fact of God, and therefore the atheist is sinful even if they don't recognize or acknowledge it. They stand in judgment for their imperfect nature, even if they don't believe in God or sin.
Note: this gets back to our "Ultimate Truth" discussion. If God exists and he is the Ultimate Truth, then that Truth is unchanging, regardless of our acceptance or rejection of the premise itself.
Most people recoil at that. But it truly is one of the most fundamental aspects of Christian doctrine:
We cannot by our effort reconcile ourselves to God, therefore we need someone else to do it. That "someone else" is Jesus Christ. By trusting in Christ and not ourselves, we gain the forgiveness for all our sins, and in God's eyes gain the full righteousness of Christ himself.This is Grace. This is what John 3:16 is all about. This is what the song Amazing Grace was written to extol. This is the Gospel.
I list the "Inherent Sinful Nature of Man" as a cornerstone because, as I mentioned, failure to grasp the reality of this prevents many people -- perhaps even myself -- from truly embracing Christ as their saviour. We instead "go through the motions" -- speak the languange, perhaps, and attend the rituals -- but in reality are trusting in ourselves rather than in Christ.
Note: Sometimes I really think I fall into the latter camp. I feel like a man standing outside the department store window, looking through the glass at the beautiful item in the display window. But I hesitate going in. The price tag says "Free," but I know the commitment to be high. It is easier to stand outside the window and preen about my supposed knowledge of what's inside the window. I am in many ways heartily ashamed of myself. I have been blessed with many things, not the least of which is a pretty good understanding of what the Christian faith is all about, and yet I stand there continuing to analyze it like some geometric proof on a blackboard. I can't shake a voice in my heart saying, "Now go, and do."
May the Lord continue to show me Mercy and Guidance.
Is sinning letting God and ourselves down?
“That leads me to the 4th Cornerstone:This is kind of interesting, the word “sin” is just a word -- and it is different in Russian, Turkish etc -- earlier we defined “sin” as a transgression of God’s law. Now you have extended “sin” into covering “bad things” (a highly relative term).
The Nature of Man - Inherently Sinful
This is not a popular topic with contemporary society. We wish to hold
that while we may do bad things on occasion, we are, overall, not that bad.”
If “sin” only covers the former case of trangressing God’s Law then I guess atheists are a bit like Bobby Fischer, they do not recognize the law that is being handed down, so they don’t believe that they are transgressing anything. For instance, a Christian might say that a Muslim is committing a sin by worshipping Allah (a false idol), but a Muslim believes that he is doing the opposite to committing a sin by worshipping Allah. The Muslim does not recognize the sin, as he does not recognize the law that is being handed down.
The obvious conclusion is that to “sin” you have to believe that there is one True God and that He handed down those laws.
If it’s the latter case, where sin covers “bad things” then we need to define what these “bad things” are. Are “bad things” only those things that trangress God’s Law? If so, then the two cases are identical. If “bad things” are a superset of the trangression of God’s Law then what are they?
You later go on to say:
"Oh, that's okay. I'll give you a pass just because I know you tried."But you meant that that really would not happen. Do you mean that God would not give you that pass unless you do something more than “try”? Or that that pass does not in fact exist (for anybody)?
I kind of agree with your #4, I think that it is in our nature to satisfy our pleasures rather than treat others as we would wish to be treated. We will satisfy our pleasures, massage our ids, even at the expense of treating others in a fashion that we would not wish to be treated ourselves.
I believe this to be true of any person in any religion.
Current song: “Don’t Let Me Down” – The Beatles
Wednesday, March 30, 2005
Cornerstone # 4 - The Nature of Man
- God's revelation in nature and in our conscience -- the key point here is that God is not a hidden God. He has chosen to reveal himself to us in a general sense. But this revelation does not take us to Christ, so more in needed.
- God's special revelation in Scripture -- because God's general revelation is insufficient for an understanding of God's nature and his desire for us his creation, God chose to reveal himself in our written word. You and I have argued over whether Scripture is inerrant. I will admit freely that believing the Bible to be inerrant is an act of faith. I believe that because I am not certain how one can establish a foundation of faith in Jesus Christ in the face of no confidence in the Bible being true.
- The nature of God: Holy, different, set apart -- the key here is that while we may have been created "in God's image" (that is, possessing qualities similar in nature to him), it would be a mistake to assume we are "like God." The chasm that separates God from us is enormous; He is utterly perfect and beyond our comprehension; we are by comparison nothing. Having a sense of God's Holy nature helps us develop a sense of reverence for him. Absent reverence, I'm not sure a trusting faith in Christ is possible.
The Nature of Man - Inherently SinfulThis is not a popular topic with contemporary society. We wish to hold that while we may do bad things on occasion, we are, overall, not that bad.
The problem with this thinking is that it allows us to hold out the glimmer of hope that we might have salvation despite our shortcomings, as if God will look upon us and say, "Oh, that's okay. I'll give you a pass just because I know you tried." Many people believe this. But the Bible doesn't teach that, and the Christian faith is definitely not based on that.
And that's why this is a cornerstone: only by finally coming to understand that we are inherently sinful -- sinful beyond our ability to fix -- do we come to a point where we give up trying and fall upon God's mercy, offered through Christ crucified and resurrected.
That's the definition of a "Christian" -- one who trusts in Jesus Christ's atoning work for our salvation, without hope in any other method of gaining God's forgiving Grace, and thus trusting in Christ as our savior we bow in obedience to his Lordship over us.
But is it true? Are we really that bad? The answer is yes, but we can only really grasp that when we compare ourselves to our best comprehension of God's Holiness. If God's true Holy nature is properly understood, we will see ourselves by comparison to be vastly inferior to him. How do we know that God is Holy? Because the Bible tells us this. How can we trust the Bible? Because we believe it to be God's written revelation. How do we know God wishes to reveal himself to us? Because we see evidence of his revelation in nature and in our consciences.
Those are my four cornerstones so far:
- God's general revelation -- suggesting he wishes to reveal himself
- God's special revelation -- in Scripture
- God's nature -- Holy, as revealed in Scripture
- Our nature -- inherently sinful, evident when we consider God's Holiness
Two more cornerstones to go.
Free Will and Foreknowledge
No, the problem I have is purely one of grasping the notion of living within a timeline versus existing outside that timeline. God is outside the timeline and therefore presumably sees everything in the timeline -- past, present and future. If God is able to see that I'll order a ham and swiss sandwich for lunch tomorrow, when tomorrow comes (for me) will my actually ordering that type of sandwich be a free will choice, or a predestined choice? Would I have the opportunity, at the very last moment, to say, "Oh! I'd rather have a chicken salad! Ha! Fooled ya, God ... you didn't see that one coming?" That can't possibly be true, otherwise God isn't truly omniscient (all knowing). Further, if God can't see into our future, then he couldn't possible direct prophecy, since he wouldn't know what was going to happen.
I do not believe God is so limited. I believe he is omniscient -- including events in the future.
Therefore, I'm back to my dilemma -- will my free choices tomorrow truly be free?
As I think about this, two things strike me:
- They will certainly appear free to me, as at the moment I make the decision I won't (likely) feel an irrestistable force directing me to make that choice.
- If God doesn't direct the choice, but merely knows what my choice will be, then the decision is mine.
My answer, then, is this: God did not force Judas to betray Jesus. Judas was faced the opportunity, and God, knowing Judas perfectly, knew that he would make the choice he did.
My brain hurts. Stop talking about free will and predestination!!
This reminds me of the Star Trek episodes where the Enterprise hurtles back in time by sling-shotting around the sun. The "Gary Seven" episode is one of my favorites, mostly because the young Terri Garr in those 60's miniskirts was wonderful. I also found it funny that when they zoomed around the sun and came rocketing back -- at Warp 11 or something like that -- it took about six paragraphs of dialog to go from Venus to the Earth, when in reality at Warp 11 it would take a microsecond.
Was "Warp Speed" a linear scale or logarithmic?
Free Willy
A “grass” in this context is someone who informs the authorities about the criminal activities of an individual. “I was grassed up to the police by him” is a common term in the UK criminal fraternity, allegedly. The East End of London shares a special affinity with the use of the word grass in this fashion. I was at a wedding on Sunday where 50% of the guests came from the East End of London so I think something rubbed off on me perhaps?
You said:
How we should treat those pawns in the Eternal Plan that unfolded in Jerusalem I'm at a loss to really say
That leads me to a few questions, firstly was Judas acting out of his Free Will or was he really a pawn?
The second thing that occurred to me was when humans acted in a way to fulfil a prophecy were they acting out of their own Free Will? Or were they forced to act in a certain way? For example:
These things happened so that the scripture would be fulfilled: “Not one of his bones will be broken,” and, as another scripture says, “They will look on the one they have pierced.”
John 19:36-37 (NIV)
Was there any other way in which the men who did this could have acted? (I assume not otherwise divine scripture would not have been fulfilled) And if not, did they really have Free Will at this time?
I have my daughter with me for the second night in a row which is an unexpected bonus that I am very thankful to The Lord for :-)
Current Song: "Stop crying your heart out" -- Oasis
PS. I have my entire CD collection ripped to mp3, at 160 kbps variable bit rate. I don't have that many songs, I have 21 days worth of continuous play, about 6500 songs which occupy 35gb or so, which is less that a biggish iPod. I use iTunes. Steve Jobs really does understand "desirability" from a physical possessions standpoint - but I think that Google are the ones to watch for new cool software.
Monday, March 28, 2005
"Nobody Likes a Grass?"
* * *
I do my best thinking in the car. Unfortunately, I soon forget it all the moment I pull the car over and park.
* * *
Do you find the "compose" function of Blogger to be somewhat maddening? More than once I've gone into the "Edit HTML" function to fix things. I find this to be particularly necessary at the transition points between "block quotes" and regular text.
* * *
How's that for some heavy thinking, huh?
Final Thoughts on Belief
Interestingly, my experience (as above) tells me that the only way that I (and therefore anyone else) can truly believe is to be touched by Him in some way, some direct intervention.I think there's something to this. I don't think on our own we would ever seek God in any earnest manner. It is only through His power that we seek and hopefully find. And maybe there's an element of free will in this as well -- some choose to believe and others choose not to. This may explain why many preachers I've heard urge people to never pass up the opportunity to commit to Christ if they find their heart so inclined at a particularl moment ... there may never be another such moment. I honestly just don't know.
I choose to believe that they are connected in the way that it says so in The Bible.That is precisely where I am as well.
Perhaps the best prayer that we can ever make is that this blessing is given to those whom we love?Amen. I am quickly coming to the understanding and belief that I should never, ever try to argue on behalf of the Bible. I'm simply no good at debating things. So if there's another I wish to help, my first course of action should be prayer on their behalf. And patience. And watchfulness, waiting for a door to open where I might help the person a little more. But going for the "slam-dunk" conversion is, I think, just foolish and wrong.
Note: the other petitionary prayer I've often thought seemed reasonable was a prayer for help seeking a deeper understanding and relationship with Christ. But then again, who am I to say what's reasonable and what's not? I'm having a crisis of conviction here, brother -- not conviction in Christ, but conviction in my sense of my understanding. Perhaps I've become to arrogant and proud, which I probably have.
* * *
From two posts ago you wrote (and I missed):
... why is Judas hated and vilified by everyone? His betrayal of Christ led to the Crucifixion and the saving of all mankind after all.That question is akin to my wondering why some people lament that Jesus should never have been crucified. I want to ask them, "What? You'd have preferred that he grow old and die some other way? Who would be your saviour then?" It's a fine line, isn't it? On the one hand we ought be grateful for the result of Christ's death, but saddened for the need for it. How we should treat those pawns in the Eternal Plan that unfolded in Jerusalem I'm at a loss to really say. Clearly not with adulation. But also not with hatred and codemnation. Pity?
* * *
Do you have all your CDs ripped to MP3 and on some massive jukebox? How exactly do you have so many different songs going?
Nobody likes a grass
My reason tells me that:
1. An omnipotent creator made this Universe
2. Truth is relative to that omnipotent creator
My experience tells me that:
There is a name “Jesus Christ” that I can pray to, and as a result “Jesus Christ” will make changes in my life
I can see no logical reason why the two should be connected, so it comes down to belief – I choose to believe that they are connected in the way that it says so in The Bible. I’m trying to come to terms with the rest of that tome, but it’s difficult -- to my eyes in has the agendas of men all over it.
Interestingly, my experience (as above) tells me that the only way that I (and therefore anyone else) can truly believe is to be touched by Him in some way, some direct intervention. We need to be involved in some way (back to Confucius). So yes, I agree that there is a selection policy, a conference (as in the act of conferring) of a blessing, as you noted in a previous append.
Perhaps the best prayer that we can ever make is that this blessing is given to those whom we love?
Also, any religion can follow my reasoning but not my experience.
- - -
Newspaper articles and (dare I say it!) Bagwellian White Papers are not held up to be inerrant. For some reason there is some odd class of folk that hold The Bible to be so :-)
- - -
I hadn't appreciated that Gibson had recut that movie, but I am glad! Thanks.
- - -
Maybe Judas is not thanked because of the title of this append?
Current Song: "Happy Place" -- The Jesus & Mary Chain
"What is Truth?" - John 18:38
We are not told how Pilate asked this question. Sincerely, or sarcastically. We are told that Pilate utters this question, and then departs Jesus. Whether this was because Jesus left the impression no answer was forthcoming, or because Pilate wasn't really interested in an answer, we just don't know.
But I think this offers a good place to leave our discussion of Truth. We'll probably never adequately define it, and we'll darn sure never prove it. The only thing I would hope is that we can both agree on one basic, fundamental thing: God Himself is the ultimate unchangeable Truth. If even that premise is up for debate, then I'm not sure on what basis any discussion on Truth can proceed.
* * *
I admire your admission that science operates on theory, and that the objective is to craft a theory that best explains past events and predicts future events. That's an honest appraisal. It is unfortunate that many wish instead to offer science as irrefutable fact, and use that assertion to ram home various agendas. It gives a bad name to both science and ideology.
* * *
How best to reconcile Matthew 27:5 and Acts 1:18 I just don't know. I'll simply provide what one commentator provides (www.carm.org, under the "Bible Difficulties" section):
That the Bible doesn't spell out all the details of every event doesn't necessarily make the Bible fallible. The writer of the above justification more or less makes that point: the two accounts don't contradict one another. It's just that the full details are not provided. If the standard by which descriptive text is to be judged is that -- every conceivable detail must be present -- well, then pretty much every document ever written fails. Certainly every single one of my white papers fails. Every newspaper story fails. Every court proceeding fails.There is no contradiction here at all because both are true. A contradiction occurs when one statement excludes the possibility of another. In fact, what happened here is that Judas went and hung himself and then his body later fell down and split open. In other words, the rope or branch of the tree probably broke due to the weight and his body fell down and his bowels spilled out.
Also, notice that Matt. 27:3-8 tells us specifically how Judas died, by hanging. Acts 1:16-19 merely tells us that he fell headlong and his bowels gushed out. Acts does not tell us that this is the means of his death where Matthew does.
When I hold that the Bible is inerrant, what I am holding to is that the Bible contains an underlying truth, as provided by God. That we may not immediately see the truth that's buried there is, I believe, by design. Had God simply provided a straight-forward, unambiguous set of truths, two things would happen: we would quickly grow bored of considering them, and we would just as quickly ignore them. The Ten Commandments are pretty unambiguous (please, no commentary on what "kill" vs. "murder" means), and they're almost universally ignored, then as well as now.
* * *
You wrote:
Absolutely. Recently here in the United States we had a news item related to a Supreme Court ruling that prohibited the death penalty for people who commit their crimes under the age of 18. The case involved a young man who at the age of 16 I think decided it would be "fun" to kill someone. He picked a victim and bound and gagged the woman. Then he drove the woman to a bridge over a river and threw the woman -- bound and gagged -- into the river, where she drowned. All for "fun." Yes, people really are capable of behaving with such relish.The savage beating he portrays Christ receiving seems too savage to me, are people really capable of behaving (with such relish) like this?
That said, it's my personal opinion that Mel Gibson played up the relish enjoyed by the Roman soldiers a bit much. I think the violence in the movie was more than was needed, and in fact detracted somewhat from the message (which is why, incidentally, Gibson has just released another cut of the movie with about 6 minutes of the more gruesome depictions removed).
An Ordinary Day
You said:
“And it is my guess that despite all the scientific jargon that they -- and no
doubt you …”
Yes I agree that scientists do far too much of this, which is a shame because the concepts of The Theories of General Relativity (GR) and Quantum Mechancis (QM) are really very simple. But the lay person gets put off by high-falutin (often Latin) terminology. The mathematics are tough, but one doesn’t need to reveal the mathematics to explain what is going on. It’s a crying shame that professionals (medical, legal, computing … whatever) invent this world that they feels sets them apart – perhaps it makes them feel safe?
On “Lighties” – they sound like delightful creatures and indeed may be “The Absolute Truth”. The first point to remember is that good scientific theories predict phenomena. The capricious whim of a “lighty” turning his handle bar is not a good theory, for instance, what is to stop the “lighty” turning it the other way? However, a “lighty” travelling in a straight line (no turning of handlebars required) through four dimensional spacetime will give the observed bend in three special dimensions. The “lighty” does not have to do anything at all except do what he was doing before, ie. travelling in a straight line. This is one of the reasons why Einstein’s GR is better than the “Lighty Theory”.
You said:
“Two objects of different mass will accelerate at the same rate absent the
effect of wind resistance?”
Yes, but I prefer to think of them carrying on as they were, moving at a uniform velocity in a straight line between two points in curved spacetime. This translates to accelerating in 3d space of course. When you think of it like this how could they possibly accelerate at different rates?
You said:
“Ever seen a quark? Ever held a neutrino in your hand and determined that it in
fact had no mass whatever? Then how do you -- deep.thought -- know that it is
true?”
I don’t know that subatomic particles such as those given the name “quark” or “neutrino” are “true” because I don’t believe that science can give us the Absolute Truth. I hold the probability of such things existing as quite high, because they help to explain how particles can have different quantum mechanical spins, and the QM spins (a theory) evidence themselves in physical properties (a fact?) of certain media. I also believe there are large chambers of water that mankind buried deep in the Earth that contain photoelectrical measuring cells that have physically measured the after effects of neutrino bursts from the sun.
Again: science does not deal with the Absolute Truth. Science deals with theories – and these theories are (and will be) modified over time.
Note 1: There are many abstract theories of science (like multiverses) which have no basis in physical evidence at all: these I do not subscribe to as science, they are more like Philosophy, and when held up as science I have a very low regard for them. But they make good reading nonetheless, just as Philosophy does.
Note 2: I studied Physics and our curriculum contained many laboratory experiments, so I have some knowledge of how scientific theory (not truth!) relates to the real world, but my direct knowledge gained through experiment is somewhat limited I agree.
You asked:
How can something be morally acceptable based on the intentional lack of
knowledge?
Well to me it could not be. But unless we agree on our morals we cannot all answer that question with the same answer can we? The question of abortion is one that will run and run for I guess as long as women (and men) decide that they want to have babies. I mentioned earlier that I believe creatures displaying moral characteristics want to preserve life, regardless of its sexual orientation. I am not judging whether being “moral” or “amoral” is good here, as I think this is something that needs looked at on a case by case basis rather than making a blanket law.
***
I watched the Passion of The Christ again on Saturday evening, I was expecting the violence this time – so I managed to look past my emotions (at times!) as to what Gibson was doing. The savage beating he portrays Christ receiving seems too savage to me, are people really capable of behaving (with such relish) like this?
The other thing I considered was Judas Iscariot. A have a couple of questions … firstly, just why is Judas hated and vilified by everyone? His betrayal of Christ led to the Crucifixion and the saving of all mankind after all.
Secondly, for the Biblical inerrant you :-) … what actually did happen to Judas after he betrayed Christ? How did he die?
Was it (as Gibson portrayed in the movie):
So Judas threw the money into the temple and left. Then he went away and hanged himself.
Matthew 27:5 (NIV)
Or:
With the reward he got for his wickedness, Judas bought a field; there he fell
headlong, his body burst open and all his intestines spilled
out.
Acts 1:18 (NIV)
Is this a simple case of a) Matthew forgetting (or not bothering) to mention that Judas went back into the temple to get the money he had thrown into it, left and then bought a field b) Acts not bothering to mention that Judas hanged himself and c) assuming both accounts are correct, they both neglected to mention that the rope broke. It’s stuff like this that Biblical inneracists come up with to shoe horn the Bible into – I just can’t accept it. Your view is appreciated!
Your Cornerstone #4, Sir?
Current Song: “The Whole of the Moon" -- The Waterboys