Saturday, June 18, 2005

Chippy?

What's a "chippy?" Is that a phrase for carpenter? Is the reference to the wood chips that tend to fly when doing woodwork?

I can't tell you how often I've mis-cut a piece of wood. Often the result is only that I must cut another. But when I'm working with a $50 sheet of plywood, I very definitely measure and re-measure, just to be certain. Still, I've goofed more than once.

* * *
You wrote:


"I know that you personally do not subscribe to natural selection/evolution"

That's not strictly true. My complaints with the theory as presently held and practiced are really this:


  • It is held as fact by many, though there are considerable scientific reasons for doubt.
  • It is often used as a means to deny God. This is done by setting up the false choice of either evolution or God. I see no theological reason why both can't apply.
  • It is widely misunderstood. Too many feel that natural selection/evolution and the changes wrought by it must make sense, as if there's a reasoning behind it. If God is that reasoning, then it works. But if the God-less notion of pure random mutation is the mechanism, then sense -- particularly forward-looking sense -- plays no role.
  • The role of "Lighties" is too often overlooked. :-)
This is where the field of "Intelligent Design" works into the discussion. I am quite frustrated by those that suggest that the Intelligent Design advocates make this claim: since something can't presently be explained, it therefore must be proof of God. I've read enough on Intelligent Design to know that the true advocates of that discipline do not make that claim. The ID claim is really more akin to: given what we know about science and our understanding of the mechanics of natural selection, how likely is it that X would occur absent a form of outside design? To my reading the thrust is not "Therefore, proof of God," but rather, "Therefore, critical shortcoming of natural selection."

The counter-argument I most frequently see from natural selection advocates is, "We have yet to discover the mechanics behind that." That's a convenient argument. The implication is that all unexplained things may one day be explained, so until then are we must assume there's a scientific explanation for it. The burden of proof is placed back on others to disprove the theory rather than proponents of it to prove it. "Until disproven, then assume true" seems to be the mantra.

With that established, then the problem becomes what constitutes sufficient evidence has been accumulated to disprove a theory? Natural selection -- as Darwin initially proposed it, not this contemporary notion of a sentient "natural force" directing things -- is a theory that has been placed on this pedestal of "Fact." Significant evidence is accumulating against the theory, but those who cling to the theory simply raise the standard for disproving it.

Note: this was my trick when arguing with my brother about "Lighties." He'd bring up every scientific refutation of my theory -- all of which decimated my theory, of course -- and I'd simply say, "No, you're not taking into account ..." and I'd make something else up.

This is why I come across as opposed to the notion of natural selection and evolution. Not because I think it by definition rules out God. But because those who cling to it do so primarily because they want so desperately to rule out God. Evolution has become for them very much a secular religion. They just won't admit it.

In many ways, the contemporary environmentalism movement has fallen into the same trap. I've known more than a few of them, and almost to a person they ascribe a kind of supernaturalism to the idea of the environment. (Which, by definition, is absurd: if anything is "of nature" it is ... um, nature.)

For the record, I see no theological problems with the idea that biological change occurred over time, and that God was the original creator and the guiding hand. I don't subscribe to the literal view of the earth being created in six days some 5,000 years ago. I also don't think Jesus is a literal door, or that heaven is literally a mustard seed. But I do believe that God is the omnipotent creator of all, and is sovereign over all things.

The Good, The Bad and The Ugly

You wrote:

I think the general view on altruism is that it's a admirable thing ... but is that good, bad or neutral?

I'm at a loss to answer this. It should be a good thing, but I know too well that what I think is a good thing another person will think is a bad thing.

I agree that it should be Fellows of The Royal Society. Tsk Tsk.

Interesting article on cancer, I may need that information one day!

On the wonders of the human body, I know that you personally do not subscribe to natural selection/evolution, but do you think that (given the environmental conditions on Earth since its inception) collections of cells becoming more complex (eg. sludge to humans) is just as likely as collections of cells becoming less complicated (eg. humans to sludge)?

(Regardless of them both being incorrect or not!)

Current song: "How many lies?" -- Spandau Ballet

PS. No idea on the mitre! A chippy once told me "measure twice and cut once". Dunno if that helps.

Nanotechnology

Another interesting article:

http://www.med.umich.edu/opm/newspage/2005/nanoparticles.htm

These two paragraphs in particular caught my eye:

Folic acid, or folate, is an important vitamin required for the healthy functioning of all cells. But cancer cells, in particular, seem to need more than average amounts. To soak up as much folate as possible, some cancer cells display more docking sites called folate receptors on their cell membranes. By taking advantage of a cancer cell's appetite for folate, U-M scientists are able to prevent the cells from developing resistance to chemotherapeutic drugs.

“It's like a Trojan horse,” Baker explains. “Folate molecules on the nanoparticle bind to receptors on tumor cell membranes and the cell immediately internalizes it, because it thinks it's getting the vitamin it needs. But while it's bringing folate across the cell membrane, the cell also draws in the methotrexate that will poison it.”

I'm fascinated by the notion of a cancer cell being "tricked" like this. I know the cell itself is not a sentient being, but at the very low chemical level, the idea that its "hunger" for folic acid would provide a means of enhancing the transport of lethal medicine is just fascinating.

And no, such things don't diminish my sense of the wonder of God and his creative works. If anything, it enhances it. He created the very stuff that makes up the molecules of folic acid, and he created the laws of chemical interaction that makes "receptors" possible. I am reminded of the Star Trek episode where Kirk is fighting the Gorn (large lizard-like being) on a planet stocked with all the necessary raw materials for offensive and defensive combat. Kirk stumbles upon a cache of sulpher, saltpeter and charcoal -- the makings of gunpowder. The crew of the Enterprise looks on, unable to intervene or help. Mr. Spock, seeing that Captain Kirk understands what he has at his disposal, says to Dr. McCoy: "Yes ... yes. He gets it, Doctor. He gets it."

There is no element of human endeavor that hasn't already been addressed in a Star Trek episode.

The Lancet takes Heat

Interesting article:

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,2-1658807,00.html

I think back to our "unethical scientists" discussion. Here we have one group, the editors at Lancet (presumably scientists, but not necessarily) being opposed by another group, the 30 fellows from the Royal Society.

Question: is the use of the term "fellow" there meant to suggest a title, or just a term of familiarity? If a title, I would have thought it would be capitalized.

I think the 30 from the Royal Society represent "science" as you view it -- striving to remain objectively neutral. Like altruism, I wonder if objective neutrality is achievable?

Altruism: Morally Neutral?

As I read your last post, it occurred to me that one thing we haven't established is whether altruism is a good thing, a bad thing, or a neutral thing. I think the general view on altruism is that it's a admirable thing ... but is that good, bad or neutral?

* * *
We have reached summer here in the desert southwest. Daily temperatures commonly hit the century mark (100 degrees Fahrenheit; 38 degrees Celcius). It's 10:45am and it's already 90F. But, surprisingly, it's not really that uncomfortable.

* * *
Imagine a room, with four walls and a ceiling. Assume the walls are plumb vertically, and square to each other and the ceiling. Now imagine a piece of crown molding set at 45-degrees to the wall and the ceiling to which it attaches. That piece of crown molding runs up to a corner formed by two walls and the ceiling. On the adjacent wall is also a piece of crown molding, of the same size and dimension, also set at 45 degrees to its wall and ceiling.

Question: what is the mathematical function that defines the relationship of the compound mitre cut that is required make the two pieces of molding match perfectly at the corner?

I've never been able to figure that out. Which explains why I've always shied away from installing crown molding. It gets even more complicated when the walls and ceiling are not plumb and square. The next time you see a finish carpenter, tip your hat ... those folks do amazing things.

Altruism

You asked:

Do you think there is such a thing as pure or true altruism?

I would define "pure or true altruism" as something that one did to move the world in such a way that did not conform to that individuals view of how the world should be.

Let me back up on that.

To explain, let me get back to motivating emotions, perhaps we do things, as you say ...

a) through fear

For example, we get up and go to work in the morning because we are scared that we cannot pay the mortgage and feed the kids otherwise. We have a worldview that we want to achieve- in this worldview we pay the mortgage and feed the kids.

Another example, Osama's man flies an aircraft into a building because he is scared that his way of life, his ideals, his religion is being threatened by America. He has a worldview that America is "wrong" and should "pay" for this, he wants to achieve his worldview and crashes the plane.

b) through hope

For example, we get up and go to work because we hope that something will happen to make us happy. Whether the happiness is obtained by helping ourselves or others is irrelevant. We have a worldview in which "happiness" is good and we want to achieve this state - the state that our view of the world says we should be in.

Osamas man crashes the plane as he hopes that this will instigate fear in the American populace, thus conforming to his worldview that the American people should feel fear.

+++

What I'm getting it at here is that we people are motivated to try to conform the world to some internally held view we have of how the world should be. It's like we all have this ideal state imagined in our minds of how things should be, and we are motivated to move the world to this ideal state. (Unfortunately these ideal states don't always coincide!)

So to me, "true altruism" is where one does something that one knows is against the ideal state one has in one's own mind of how things should be.

So the examples you gave are not "pure or true altruism", for the very reasons that you pointed out.

I'm not sure human beings are capable of "pure or true altruism" by my definition .... I cannot believe that the Pope would sincerely pray to Allah, or that a non-religious person would sincerely pray to any deity.

Current song: "Ironic" -- Alanis Morissette

Sunday, June 12, 2005

Fear and Hope

Several years ago I was speaking with a gentleman for whom I had considerable regard. He said that there are two primary emotions: fear and hope. All other emotions are secondary to those. I didn't really understand that statement at the time, perhaps because at that time I did not have the same awareness of hope as I do now. Fear I understood then as now, and much of my life is still geared to my responses to basic fear.

I recall that conversation on fear being the primary driver of human behavior. If I'm not mistaken, that conversation took place in a restaurant in Poughkeepsie, NY. I forget the restaurant now ... it was not the Hyde Park Brewery, that I know.

As I think more about the question you posed, I wonder if most of our immediate actions are based on fear, but what generates our fear is a lack of hope. I say with fair certainty that I fear the future and what it may hold for me. The question I need to ask myself is this: is my fear based on a lack of hope for the future? By hope I do not mean some kind of wishful thinking, but rather a settled trust that what will become of me is what is ultimately best for me. That's a hard, hard thing to really believe.

Is there such a thing as true altruism? Maybe ... I think of cases where people sacrifice themselves so their children may live. But might there be a shred of selfishness in that -- wishing one's DNA to live on in one's children? How about soldiers who throw themselves on live grenades? True altruism, or perhaps heroics tainted with a degree of desire for glory? I honestly don't know.

What are your thoughts? Do you think there is such a thing as pure or true altruism?

Motivation

Kind sir you wrote:

"Is there anything in which we can truly place our trust?" That, I think, is what animates virtually all human endeavors.

This reminds me of a discussion we had years ago. I seem to recall us coming to some kind of tacit understanding that it was fear that motivated the majority of human behaviour.

Looking at it today, what would you say are the fundemental motivators behind human behaviour? I would say firstly that it depends on you stage in life, as children tend to be motivated by different things compared to old age folk.

Certainly a child is seeking to trust someone, but by the time they get to a ripe old age they are very wary about trusting anyone, but perhaps they still want to?

What are the fundamental drivers of why we humans do things?

To lower our fear or to avoid fear?
Pleasure seeking?

Is there such a thing as "true altruism"? Or do we always gain some pleasure from our sacrifice?

Something else?

Your thoughts kind sir!

Current song: "Tubthumping" -- Chumbawumba

Saturday, June 11, 2005

Questionable Texts

Probably more than we realize. Ultimately this brings us back to the foundational question of our times: "Is there anything in which we can truly place our trust?" That, I think, is what animates virtually all human endeavors. We humans seem to be creatures who long for a place to return; as if in our present existence we are adrift.

Unethical scientists

http://science.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=05/06/10/1243222

Seems to be quite prevalent. I wonder how many other texts have been changed to fit "the facts"?

Friday, June 10, 2005

What is ...

If your last post was a "Jeopardy!" answer, then I'll respond in the form of a question:

What is the British alt-rock band from the 70's and 80's who produced stylish yet utterly undanceable music?

:-)

YES

Believing It True; Therefore, Believing

I often ask people if they believe there is an "absolute truth." It's quite amazing how many people -- even people who claim to be Christians -- find it difficult to say yes. Now proving that Truth and believing that it exists are two quite different things.

If I thought that the Christian worldview was just one of many from which I might choose, I would never have settled upon it. If in fact all religions were indeed equally valid, in my heart I'd sense the common untruth of all and probably continue in an agnostic way.

I'm really not trying to sound combative or boastful or anything like that here ... I'm just trying to express what my mind and heart has latched onto. It's the equation I've written about before: If the central claims of Jesus are false, then Christianity is a worthless religion; but if they are true, then the implications are enormous. I choose to believe they are true; therefore, the implications are enormous.

Of late I am sensing an enormous something in my heart, as if God is nudging me to go in some direction. There is an elevated sense of the Truth of Christ, and this has come about without a concerted effort on my part to "believe more" than I did before. My mind has moved past some of the nagging doubts from the recent past and they are now in the "settled" category. There is a powerful sense to not debate or argue about it any more. It's almost as if the Lord is telling me, "Your path is not that way, come this way." I am, of course, resisting because of the unknown. But the change is there. It is real.

The other night I was visiting with friends back in Virginia, and as we sat out in the garage drinking bourbon and smoking cigars (in the garage because it was raining), the wife of the couple opened up and was expressing some painful and deeply personal things to me. From what I know of her, that was a difficult thing to do. This is not an uncommon occurrence: I frequently find people telling me things like this. Perhaps there is an awareness of trust, or empathy, or something. But it got me wondering ... could this be my calling? Am I being asked to pursue a path of pastoral counseling, or something like that? I have no training in that area, and my listening skills are weak. I'm not rushing to make this decision, but I am wondering.

May the blessings of our Lord Jesus be upon you, my dear friend.

Thursday, June 09, 2005

In the name of God

But as the assertion becomes more specific ("God is 5'9" tall and has a pet schnauzer named 'Max'") then the probability of none being correct elevates

Lol! Or that God has a name, for example "YHWH". I agree :-)

The same holds for scientific theory, does it not? All the theories about the origins of the universe may be wrong.

Almost definitely are wrong. I would assert that the real "truth" of the matter cannot be found out by the software running in the ram. The software will see what you (the thing outside the Universe) tells it is there.

I fear is two aspects of death: what happens on the way to death (suffering)

Yes me too, and the suffering of those that love you.

, and what happens after death.

After death you might just go back into the state you were in before birth, you have no complaints about a rainy tuesday in the pre-Cambrian period about 500,000,000 years ago do you? (Maybe I assume too much!)

The prospect of being held accountable for all my thoughts, deeds and actions is what I fear.

Then you fear the Christian religion my friend. Become a Buddhist and you won't have this fear any longer!

Current song: "My Death" -- David Bowie (originally a Jacques Brel song)

My death waits like an old roué
So confident I will go his way
Whistle to him
And the passing time
My death waits like a Bible truth

.. Jolly old number !!

I Fear the Probability of Proof

You asked:
Isn't it more likely than none are correct?

I'll grant that the possibility of none being correct is there. I can't venture a guess as to the probability of it. I suppose that would depend on what exactly is the assertion of each. The more generic the assertion ("A higher being created the universe") then the probability of none being correct is low. But as the assertion becomes more specific ("God is 5'9" tall and has a pet schnauzer named 'Max'") then the probability of none being correct elevates.

The same holds for scientific theory, does it not? All the theories about the origins of the universe may be wrong. Well, except my "Lighty" theory, of course. :-)

What do I fear? Death, of course ... but if I really think about it what I fear is two aspects of death: what happens on the way to death (suffering), and what happens after death. I've never in my life been a true atheist. Rather, I've always assumed that I'd somehow be shown mercy. But I was never completely convinced of that; rather it was a hope. The prospect of being held accountable for all my thoughts, deeds and actions is what I fear. That fear is accentuated when I consider the standard by which I might be judged. A low bar provides little fear; hence the desire to think that post-death judgment is lax. But a high bar strikes terror. And a bar set at "perfect" is what brought me to Christ.

Fear

Yes - agreed that religion assumes that God exists and builds from there. But each religion has a different God, so each religion has built something different. As you pointed out, only one can be correct. Isn't it more likely than none are correct? That is a purely probabilistic question for you.

When you write:

But science cannot save us from what in our hearts we fear the most

What do you in your heart fear the most? Do you know?

Current song: "Acquiesce" -- Oasis

Wednesday, June 08, 2005

Proof

You wrote:
Science looks for things to disprove current theory, Religion looks for
things to re-inforce its current theory.

I'm not going to dispute the central point here. In general science does not rest on its current discoveries; it continues to assert hypothesis and test those to see if they yield new results. Theology does not operate in that manner -- it does not set out to disprove itself.

There's a fundamental difference here. The basic assumption of science is that all things are subject to potential disproving. Theology is based on a cornerstone that cannot be disproved -- the existence and nature of God. At the very core of Theology is a belief that God exists, based on an understanding of his general and specific revelation. The focus is fundamentally different.

Science is an important part of this world. But science cannot save us from what in our hearts we fear the most. I cannot prove that. But I know it.

The long and winding road

Ok I get what you are saying about the logical links between the Christian Faith and the tenet of a sovereign God.

When you say:

The faith can only be made stronger by searching out such vulnerable spots and understanding the possible arguments that might be made.

This is what I was saying earlier about the difference between science and religion (something that I heard someone else say by the way, but that struck a chord).

Science looks for things to disprove current theory, Religion looks for things to re-inforce it's current theory. If this is so, which approach will best lead to "the truth"?

Current song: "What if" - Coldplay (well in my head anyway, at work!)

Monday, June 06, 2005

Tumbling Faith

No, I'm not trying to say that our theological structure needs to be built only on provable things. Ultimately that would be impossible -- God himself has chosen, apparently, to hide from us things that would irrefutably prove his existence. So by necessity we must build our faith structure on just that ... faith.

What I was trying to get at was that the theological structure is held together by certain logical constructs. For instance, it should go without saying that if God does not exist, then whether Jesus was the messiah or not is entirely moot. Therefore, a necessary precondition for the Christian theological structure is a stipulation that God does in fact exist. If that matter is unsettled, then there's little reason to explore more minute details of the faith, such as whether Jesus really did feed the 5,000.

Similarly, I'd argue that the total sovereignty of God is another such precondition, though it's a less obvious precondition than the one I used in the previous paragraph. But if God is not entirely sovereign, then it's hard to hold the rest of the logical structure together. I suppose one could argue that he has sufficient authority, but not complete. But what a mess that creates if God has some authority but not complete sovereignty. Questions then boil to the surface: where does his authority start and end? What can he do and what can he not do? Etc., etc.

Note: that's precisely the position of "Open View Theism," which believes that God is not completely sovereign, and that he is learning as he goes along, making mistakes and trying to do better next time. I find the concept of that just silly. Why bother with a god that's little better than ourselves?

I'm more convinced of God's existence and sovereignty than ever before. I can't prove a lick of it, but to my mind and my heart, it makes no difference. I believe it.

But ... it sure is a fascinating mental exercise to map out the logical construct and see where the vulnerable spots are. "If X is not true, then Y occurs ... " Some might brand me a heretic for even considering such things, but that's precisely what theology is. The faith can only be made stronger by searching out such vulnerable spots and understanding the possible arguments that might be made.

Faith

Man your email to the lighty had me laughing, in the words from the movie Goodfellas ... "you're a funny guy!"

When you write:

If that's the case, then the entire theological structure comes tumbling down.

But that is exactly what faith means. We build our theological structure on unprovable things and we have faith that they are true. We cannot know 100%. You think perhaps we should not build our theological structure on unprovable things? Or in other words, should we only build it on things that we know to be 100% true?

Current song: "Fix you" -- Coldplay

PS. The new Coldplay album c'est magnific, marrying a real-life Hollywood Princess and becoming a father does not seem to have dented Chris Martin's edge.