Tuesday, January 23, 2007

Objection! Leading the Witness!

Do you see where I am coming from on this? Forcing people down an alley in their answer.

Let
me pose four scenarios:
  1. "There are two choices: X and Y. Which of the two do you prefer?"
  2. "I believe there are two choices: X and Y. Which of the two do you prefer?"
  3. "Others have said there are two choices: X and Y. Which of the two do you prefer?"
  4. "For the purposes of this discussion, let's assume two choices: X and Y. Which of the two do you prefer?"
Would you find an objection with any of those?

You seem to indicate that making a declarative statement is okay, since it's then up to the listener to believe it or not ("Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me." John 14:6, KJV). Jesus never asked anyone to choose between alternatives. I'd gather you'd be okay with the declarative portion of #1, but not the question posed later?

If you have a problem with all four of them, are you then suggesting that it is invalid to suggest a limited set of alternatives when there is always the possibility that other options exist ... even ones we do not yet know about?

Monday, January 22, 2007

Control

Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me

This is fine, one can choose to believe it or not.

If Jesus had said to a third person, "Do you believe that I am the way, the truth or the light?" then that would be a Lewis-ism. There is no way out, no option that says "Hey, I believe none of those".

Do you see where I am coming from on this? Forcing people down an alley in their answer.

"Self-Evidently Incomplete"

I look at all the available evidence and come up with an "on balance of probability" statement that I can accept.
  • You accepted: John 14:6 (King James Version)
  • You rejected: Matthew 20:1-16
Both are attributed utterances of Jesus. Unless you're more of a Bible scholar than I'm aware, I can't see on what basis you would "on balance of probability" believe John but discredit Matthew.

Plus, Matthew 20:1-16 is a parable ... Jesus is using it to make a larger point he wished to make at that time. The fact that you are able to posit alternative reasons for the made-up workers' discontent does not mean Jesus was trying to be "self evidently incomplete."

If you believe Matthew 20:1-16 is an unreliable representation of what Jesus said based on your self-detected "Lewis-ism," then I would imagine you should have also rejected John 14:6:
Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me
Problems:
  • The "way, the truth, and the life" is an incomplete list. There are other things he may be.
  • "No man cometh" is a statement of certainty in an uncertain world
I'd imagine much of the Bible is in jeopardy using this standard. That, of course, may be your larger point.

Misdirection

If you wish to claim some passages as reliable and others suspect, what do you use to decide which is which?

Similar to a way a human judge in a Court works, I look at all the available evidence and come up with an "on balance of probability" statement that I can accept.

Clearly some statements cannot be proved or disproved, so these are more likely to be believed on face value than not, by me. Some other statements, such as Lewis-isms, are self-evidently incomplete, in my opinion.

If someone tells you that there are two colors and two colors only you know that they are not telling you what you have measured with your own senses don't you? Maybe they are just blinded to the other colors and are telling as much of the way it is as they know, or maybe they have a hidden agenda? If it is the latter then what could that hidden agenda be?

For what the hidden agenda is, Lewis might say "It could be (X) or it could be (Y) - which do you think?" So the recipient of the Lewis-ism goes down the path of X or Y, falling into the trap laid down by Lewis. It could be that the agenda is (Z) - couldn't it?

Maybe not "false choices", but certainly "incomplete choices".

I first came across this blatant steering when I read "Mere Christianity", which is why I refer to it as a Lewis-ism. But since then, I have noticed that many who assume a position of power do this and that it is one of the chief mechanisms used by senior people on their subordinates. Just an observation.

Sunday, January 21, 2007

Inconsistencies

We don't know that Jesus said it do we?

Well for starters:
John 14:6 (King James Version)

Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me
Which is it? Is the Bible a reliable or unreliable witness to what Jesus said?

If you wish to claim some passages as reliable and others suspect, what do you use to decide which is which?

Fait accomplis

  1. How is someting Jesus said a "Lewis-ism?"
  2. How do you know your interpretation is correct?
1. We don't know that Jesus said it do we? It could have been written by a person with a similar mind to Lewis, by mind of Lewis I mean this:

"I will only present a limited number of options to you in the hope that you pick one, or at least feel some compulsion to pick one, thus closing the debate down to the topics of my chosing".

I refer to such a passage as a Lewis-ism. No temporal causality implied!

2. I don't, and I apologize for making it look it is. But it might be. The very fact that I can posit alternatives to the two choices given at all shows that the two choices given are not enough, doesn't it?

Lewis-isms

The response given by the landowner is:

(a) Don't I have the right to do what I want with my own money? Or (b) are you envious because I am generous?'

Now isn't this a classic case of Lewis-ism? Ie, providing two possible solutions to a question where there are more than two solutions.

The workers are grumbling because they wished they had only worked a short time rather than the whole day.

Questions:
  1. How is someting Jesus said a "Lewis-ism?"
  2. How do you know your interpretation is correct?

Socialized synapses

When they received it, they began to grumble against the landowner

The response given by the landowner is:

(a) Don't I have the right to do what I want with my own money? Or (b) are you envious because I am generous?'

Now isn't this a classic case of Lewis-ism? Ie, providing two possible solutions to a question where there are more than two solutions.

The workers are grumbling because they wished they had only worked a short time rather than the whole day. Why did they wish this? Perhaps during that time they could have done other work, thus being paid net more for the day? Or enjoyed some leisure time with their friends?

Perhaps they are also grumbling because -- being creatures formed through natural selection -- they are compelled to try to obtain some advantage over their fellow man, and in this case they have done the opposite, their fellow men - who worked only a little - got an advantage over them.

I think the answer given in this parable is strongly suggesting (to me anyway) that we deny those feelings of "get one up on our fellow man" -- that answer leads to an excellent lesson for all of us. It's in total harmony with the Golden Rule and the second commandment of the New Covenant. I constantly get the feeling that Jesus is trying to tell us to use the socialized mind to override the body, in some sense.

We already have instinctual synapses from birth but our education forms new synapses, pathways in the brain. Do you feel that Jesus is recommending to us that we follow the impulses from the socialized synapses rather than the instinctual ones? I get that feeling a lot of the time. It's a balance, some complex interplay going on in the brain.

+++

Because what I'm finding is that for all the intellectual fun I might have debating some theological point, the truth is I'm not coming closer to Christ himself in the process.

This is a "spiritual" (whatever that is) process. It's emotional in root and in my opinion for this journey you either need hard evidence (like I feel I have) or many years of conditioning your synapses so that absolute belief becomes the norm. My only advice is to look for the evidence, pray and keep an open mind.

For me, there's something else ... some other calling for me. One that doesn't draw me close to the as-yet-untransformed parts of my heart that is ruled by pride, arrogance, fear and insecurity.

These parts of your heart are parts of your brain in reality as you know. And the emotions there are shaped by structures in the brain that can be reshaped through exercising your brain in other directions. This has been shown in pictures taken of the synapses in the brain. Brainwashing will work, it's close to proven through direct observation of the brain.

So have you had any revelation about your other calling? At one point you were considering Pastor-hood?

You can't imagine -- you simply can't imagine -- how much I yearn to drop my sword and shield and really come unto Him to find rest.

This will happen upon your death - I hope that you don't want to die .. be careful for what you wish for pal!

Life is good. We have been given this precious, fleeting ... gift. I have seen people in the cancer ward die early. It's sad. Life should be prolonged as long as possible in my opinion.

If you want to 100% believe in Christ in this life then I believe that you need to do some serious brain reprogramming, which is possible, or go find The Living Christ, He is there, and I really don't think you'll find him in a Church, but that doesn't mean He is not there in The Church, just my warped view of religions probably.

Who was it that said "God is spirit and religion is politics"? I can't find it on Google but I didn't make it up either.

Saturday, January 20, 2007

Chances

In that case, if the Muslim still rejects Jesus then he goes to eternal damnation. Alternatively if the Muslim does accept Jesus then all the mosque-work done throughout the life of the Muslim is put aside with an "ok you were unlucky to be born in downtown Baghdad but at least in the end you made the right decision, you may enter".

Maybe. Maybe not. I don't know. But would you agree it's a possibility? There's a hint of something along these lines in the parable offered in Matthew 20:1-16:
"For the kingdom of heaven is like a landowner who went out early in the morning to hire men to work in his vineyard. He agreed to pay them a denarius for the day and sent them into his vineyard.

"About the third hour he went out and saw others standing in the marketplace doing nothing. He told them, 'You also go and work in my vineyard, and I will pay you whatever is right.' So they went.

"He went out again about the sixth hour and the ninth hour and did the same thing. About the eleventh hour he went out and found still others standing around. He asked them, 'Why have you been standing here all day long doing nothing?'

" 'Because no one has hired us,' they answered.
"He said to them, 'You also go and work in my vineyard.'

"When evening came, the owner of the vineyard said to his foreman, 'Call the workers and pay them their wages, beginning with the last ones hired and going on to the first.'

"The workers who were hired about the eleventh hour came and each received a denarius. So when those came who were hired first, they expected to receive more. But each one of them also received a denarius. When they received it, they began to grumble against the landowner. 'These men who were hired last worked only one hour,' they said, 'and you have made them equal to us who have borne the burden of the work and the heat of the day.'

"But he answered one of them, 'Friend, I am not being unfair to you. Didn't you agree to work for a denarius? Take your pay and go. I want to give the man who was hired last the same as I gave you. Don't I have the right to do what I want with my own money? Or are you envious because I am generous?'

Matthew 20:1-16, NIV

It may be that an ocean of people who followed other religions get into heaven. It may be they do not. But whatever happens, to me it seems two things are clear:
  • Based on Matthew 20:1-16, it would seem to me our proper response should be at worst contentment with what we have received; at best joy for those saved.
  • If Jesus is making the decision, then the decision must be just and right. Unless God is really arbitrary and capricious. But I don't believe that. So again, if God is perfectly just, and God is making the final decisions, then those final decisions are just ... whatever they may turn out to be.
Note: I hope you noticed that I couched that earlier post in language suggesting I was simply reporting what others believe. Honestly, I don't really know what the mechanics of this will be, or should be.

* * *
John 14:6 (King James Version)

Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me.

That's what it says. What does that mean? Is there potential latitude in the possible interpretations? I would think so, but I'm not sure I'm prepared to justify one interpretation and dismiss another.

* * *
It may sound like I'm getting all squishy and liberal ... and in some sense that may be true. To be honest, I'm just bone weary of reading and hearing and, to some degree, participating in debates about things that to me seem to tangential ... not so much from you, but just in general. So I continue to ponder what is the absolute essence of the Christian faith.

Because what I'm finding is that for all the intellectual fun I might have debating some theological point, the truth is I'm not coming closer to Christ himself in the process. For me, there's something else ... some other calling for me. One that doesn't draw me close to the as-yet-untransformed parts of my heart that is ruled by pride, arrogance, fear and insecurity.

You can't imagine -- you simply can't imagine -- how much I yearn to drop my sword and shield and really come unto Him to find rest.

Fat chance

Why should that not also include trusting him to do what is right and just with all those people for whom you are concerned?

Well for starters:
John 14:6 (King James Version)

Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me.
So clearly in this life the person born in downtown Baghdad -- who is very likely to become a Muslim let's face it -- has little chance of coming to God.

that upon death one comes before Jesus, and at that point they have a final opportunity to reject or accept him.

Well that's the answer then. The Muslim dies, he's standing in front of Jesus, looking around for any sign of Mohammed and not finding him. He just sees Jesus before him. In that case, if the Muslim still rejects Jesus then he goes to eternal damnation. Alternatively if the Muslim does accept Jesus then all the mosque-work done throughout the life of the Muslim is put aside with an "ok you were unlucky to be born in downtown Baghdad but at least in the end you made the right decision, you may enter".

Thursday, January 18, 2007

The Joys of "Chili Spaghetti"

So help me, I do love it so.*

Since at least when I was in my 20's, I have enjoyed the simple pleasure of a pile of steaming spaghetti smothered in a good chili, covered with cheddar cheese and Tabasco hot sauce. I am having that tonight. It is yummy.

And it seems that true spaghetti -- the long, thin stuff -- is key. Elbow macaroni or any other shape doesn't seem to taste as good. I know that pasta is pasta. But for some reason, the long spaghetti strikes my palette best.

* Note: a thin reference to a line from the movie "Patton." General Patton is on a hillside, overlooking the aftermath of a battle. He surveys the carnage, and comments how there is nothing in all of human endeavor he loves as much. "I love it. God help me, I love it so."

Wednesday, January 17, 2007

The Source of Justice

Yes but what about someone born in downtown Baghdad? They are in a completely different spot to the person from the Amazon jungle. It's drummed into their head from day zero that Allah and Mohammed are the way, not Jesus.

We are called to believe that this is "just"? Maybe we are but it doesn't seem so. I know I know, it's because we (or at least I) cannot see the big picture :)

No, you misunderstood what I said. There is much on this earth that is not just. The world itself is broken. I'm not aware of any scriptural indication that what transpires on this earth -- in the hands of evil men -- is guaranteed to be right and just.

Note: a greater degree of justice would be that those carrying the message of Christ would be allowed to present their case, and leave the decision to accept or reject that message up to the listener. Of course, in many countries that's not permitted. The message is prohibited by the actions of fallen man. Prohibiting the message is an unjust act instituted by man, not God.

What I said was that God himself is just. And that in the end, when this earth is gone and God calls everyone to account, whatever judgment befalls the person from downtown Baghdad will be a just decision.

I acknowledge that one could argue that the fact there is injustice in this world is evidence that God is himself not just. I don't agree with that argument, but I grant that it is an argument.

Dallas Willard -- not your favorite, I know -- said once, "I don't know who will be saved, but I know that it will be Jesus that does the saving." His point is that while we don't know for certain the exact mechanism and criteria of salvation, we can rely on Christ being the agent of salvation.

There are some -- whether Willard falls in this camp I do not know -- that hold that upon death one comes before Jesus, and at that point they have a final opportunity to reject or accept him. Further, some argue that in the presence of the risen Christ, all will come to Him. They cite the verses:
By myself I have sworn, my mouth has uttered in all integrity a word that will not be revoked: Before me every knee will bow; by me every tongue will swear.
(Isaiah 45:23, NIV)
and in particular:
Therefore God exalted him to the highest place and gave him the name that is above every name, that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, in heaven and on earth and under earth, and every tongue confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father. (Philippians 2:9-11, NIV)
Whether this is a true and correct interpretation of scripture, I do not know.

Ultimately, we -- you and I -- are called to "trust Jesus." Why should that not also include trusting him to do what is right and just with all those people for whom you are concerned?

Justice

Someone deep in the Amazon jungle who has never heard of Jesus is in a completely different spot than someone in Rochester

Yes but what about someone born in downtown Baghdad? They are in a completely different spot to the person from the Amazon jungle. It's drummed into their head from day zero that Allah and Mohammed are the way, not Jesus.

We are called to believe that this is "just"? Maybe we are but it doesn't seem so. I know I know, it's because we (or at least I) cannot see the big picture :)

Tuesday, January 16, 2007

Salvation

Question: why should where you are born have such an impact on your chances of being saved? It's not fair. Someone born in Rochester Minnesota is a lot more likely to be saved than someone born in downtown Baghdad.

You know, I honestly don't know. It's my opinion that the critical thing is rejection of knowledge, not lack of knowledge. Someone deep in the Amazon jungle who has never heard of Jesus is in a completely different spot than someone in Rochester, Minnesota who has had ample opportunity to learn of Christ, but consciously rejected Him.

But again, I honestly have no idea.

The key thing, I believe, is to rest on the belief that God is, among many things, perfectly just. No matter the ultimate outcome, whatever it may be, we are called to believe it'll not be arbitrary and capricious, but perfectly just.

Sunday, January 14, 2007

Comet McNaught

A nice video and you can see Mercury close to the Sun also. Should be visible at dawn/dusk tomorrow also (dusk is still today for you at time of writing).

http://www.space.com/spacewatch/soho_lasco_c3_live.html

Anti-human mode?

First let me say that I concur with you 100% on your thoughts about the Beckham transfer to LA. It's the same as the Pele story. I would add that the UK public generally like "Posh & Becks" as Victoria and David Beckham are known as. It's understood that his physical powers are on the wane and on the whole I think people wish him luck.

And I agree that the US public will not take to soccer as they have done to football. Part of this is the human propensity to show a preference for things that are familiar.

+++

I will not accept one set of rules that applies to me, but does not apply to her. After that, pretty much everything boils down to the trivial.

Interesting here is that you are not asking to "get one up" on your spouse. Is this anti-human behavior as laid down by "survival of the fittest"? Sounds like all you want is equality?

+++

Question: why should where you are born have such an impact on your chances of being saved? It's ntot fair. Someone born in Rochester Minnesota is a lot more likely to be saved than someone born in downtown Baghdad. I have mentioned this before. Well, I guess the world just isn't fair. Either way, I am certainly glad that I was born in a place that afforded me at least a good chance of salvation :)

+++

You are right, I am such a mom! K had a sleepover (slumber party) at our house with a friend last night and spent this afternoon at same friends house. All arranged on the fly with no stress from either the other parents or myself. Something that was impossible in the days when K's mother was in the saddle. K gives me feedback, she tells me how much happier she is now. Thank You Lord and I pray please keep K happy.

I bought her some new school trousers (pants) this weekend. Goodness knows what K's mum does with all the money I send her. K was wearing hand-me-down trousers from her sister that were far too short for her and all shiny from being directly ironed. Everyone knows you need to put a cloth between the hot serface of the iron and the childs trousers! As I said - I am such a mom :)

Thursday, January 11, 2007

Bend it Like Beckham

The big sports news here -- perhaps there as well -- is that David Beckham has signed with the Los Angeles Galaxy of the MLS. The deal, worth reportedly $250M, is being touted as the start of a renaissance for "soccer" here in the U.S.

I don't believe a word of it. I believe that he signed, and I believe the deal is worth lots of money. I just doubt it'll mean much in terms of how the U.S. embraces soccer or how the international community views U.S. soccer.

I'm reminded of the 1970's when Brazilian star Pele came north to play for the professional soccer league in existence at that time. Lots of fanfare; very little lasting result.

Note: yes, soccer is quiet popular among the young here in the United States. Tons of soccer leagues. Kids rarely go out for baseball any more, which explains why the sport of baseball is increasingly dominated by the Latin Americans and the Japanese. But all that youthful enthusiasm hasn't translated into much. It's been bandied about for 30 years, yet professional soccer is marginal at best in the U.S. College soccer is lightly attended.

I'm not disparaging soccer ... I'm just pointing out the obvious: soccer just doesn't command the attention of the American public. Probably the same way in which NASCAR auto racing isn't a big thing over there.


The same holds true for this, I believe. I have three reasons for thinking this:
  1. Soccer just can't break into the U.S. sports attention span, with football, basketball and baseball already competing for the time and dollars, as well as being firmly entrenched in the American psyche.
  2. David Beckham may still be good, but I doubt anyone seriously considers him the best in the world any more. He may one day have been that, but at 31 (?) he has to be in the twilight of his career. That mirrors Pele's coming to America. He was well past his prime when he signed on with the New York team.
  3. Finally, I have a hunch -- I don't generally follow these things -- but I have a hunch that he's passed from the roles of sports heroes to celebrity weenies some years back. In other words, he's not taken seriously as a soccer player any more, but rather as a limelight sucking celebrity. Would I be correct in that assessment?
My prediction is there'll be much fanfare, lost of publicity, and a great big collective yawn in the United States. In a few years he'll announce his retirement, there'll be much talk about how he energized the sport in America, and he'll try his hand in movies or something. But it'll all be much about nothing.

Am I being too cynical? Do you see this recent development as anything really all that exciting from a purely sport perspective, as opposed to a celebrity perspective?

Seethe

"Seethe" -- I like that word. It sounds like what it means.

That seething resentment is exactly how a child feels as it is taught to "treat others as it wishes to be treated" - and this is to be expected. The Golden Rule goes against the natural propensity of a race borne out of natural selection which wants to get one up on it's fellow man. The Golden Rule needs to be taught to us when we are young and it's a painful lesson to learn.

I have no disagreement with this whatever.

But for the Christian, who understands that Jesus was after a transformed heart, is it proper to seethe inside and not at least want to correct that? I would argue the desire to do what Christ would want of us should be present. Absent that -- or, put another way, if seething inside is seen as perfectly acceptable -- I would question exactly how well one really knows Jesus.

I think Children understand this better than we may think they do. I agree that teaching them the Golden Rule is critical and painful. But I'll bet somewhere in their minds they know that there's a odd disconnect going on when they act nicey-nice but feel hateful inside. Would you say that's true?

I've been thinking alot about obedience to Jesus and a kind of hierarchy of submission. It is this: strive first to control the things that are obvious and outward -- what I say, how I act. Then, when that develops into a habit, focus on the internal things: what I'm thinking about others. Only then try to tackle the big ones -- pride, envy, etc.

I think this is Biblically supported. James, I think, writes of curbing one's tongue first and foremost. The Proverbs do as well. That makes some sense. We all can control what we say ... saying hateful and spiteful things is always a deliberate act. Thinking hateful and spiteful things is something different.

* * *
I cannot change them, I can only change myself. By avoiding them I don't make enemies, but then Churchill would say I am not standing up for something. But some things are more equal than others in the "worth standing up for" stakes - wouldn't you agree?

Oh, absolutely. One of my number one rules of marriage is this: come to an understanding about what's really important, and stand on those principles. But do not make everything a principled stand. My number one rule is this: I will not accept one set of rules that applies to me, but does not apply to her. After that, pretty much everything boils down to the trivial.

The same holds for me at work -- I raise problems to management only rarely. But I've found that when I do raise the flag, they respond. Choosing one's battles is important. I'm sure Churchill would have agreed with that. There's a subtle distinction in Churchill's quote: someone with no enemies has no principles; but someone who has no allies is picking too many fights.

You can quote me on that. :-)

Wednesday, January 10, 2007

Where Fault Lies

This may be a surprise to some, but I can categorically say that it is a relief for a child to know that such differences are caused by something beyond their control.

I can well imagine that would be true. And what an awful feeling to think that some genetic malady is your fault. Good for K to have this measure of relief in her heart. Good for you to use Legos effectively as a teaching tool.

But you can't fool me. I know you were just playing with the Legos. She came along and caught you. In a moment of embarrassment, you thought you'd fool her by turning it into a teaching moment. She's onto you though. She probably told everyone at school, "My daddy plays with blocks!"

Quotes

"It has been my experience that folks who have no vices have very few virtues." Abraham Lincoln

Is that a truism, or merely a common trait observed by Lincoln? In other words, is there reason to believe that vices contribute to more or more pronounced virtues? I can't imagine why that would be the case. But it could be that Lincoln was making an observation on an aspect of human nature. Some have a tendency to slip into a kind of muddled complacency, with no particular vices and no particular virtues. But those who live more deliberately step out of that safe ground. Their virtues are many, but by the nature of humans so are their vices.

"You have enemies? Good. That means you've stood up for something, sometime in your life." Winston Churchill

I think this would be related to the Lincoln observation. The only way to avoid having enemies is to become so pliable that you end up having no particular principles. That's one of the animating elements of politics. Some of the most admired politicians are, in fact, the ones who stood up to principle. Churchill being an excellent example. Harry Truman, president immediately after Roosevelt and before Eisenhower being another. Sometimes, however, it takes time for people see and appreciate the strength.

I struggle with this. I'm so deeply programmed to avoid rocking the boat that I tend to avoid standing firm on anything. It's not that I'm obviously two-faced, it's that I shy away from taking stands at all.

"One of the common failings among honorable people is a failure to appreciate how thoroughly dishonorable some other people can be, and how dangerous it is to trust them." Thomas Sowell

Indeed. As a side note, Thomas Sowell is black professor at Stanford University in Palo Alto and a fellow at the Hoover Institute there. He is a prolific author and staunch conservative. And, as mentioned, he's black. Therefore, in liberal American circles, "black and conservative" is to be reviled. And he is. But conservatives love him. With no particular regard to his skin color.

I'm trying to place this in the context of biblical teaching. I'm not convinced Jesus taught us to go out and be blindingly trusting of others. In fact, there's considerable admonition to assess others carefully -- to avoid wasting the good things of God on those who will trample it; and to avoid false teachers, who seek to tempt the weak into damnation.

How does one be open and loving and properly wary of those who should not be trusted? I have no idea whatever.